Questions tagged [race-condition]

A race condition is when multiple threads/processes/clients all use a resource, without proper use of locks.

A race condition is when multiple threads/processes/clients all use a resource, without the proper use of locks.

In multi-threaded programs, race conditions occur because context switches between threads are often erratic and unpredictable, often causing a shared value to change at inopportune times.

Servers are also vulnerable to race conditions, sometimes more so, because there are many independent clients which act independently, as well as delays caused by network communication.

Consider the example of two people simultaneously editing the same document:

  1. Person #1 sees an incorrect line. #1 begins to fix this line, but is a slow typist.
  2. Person #2 sees the same mistake - while #1 is typing - and fixes it.
  3. #1 and #2 commit their edited documents at the same time, without the other being notified.
  4. #1's change reaches the server first, and the server writes it to disk.
  5. #2's change reaches the server later, and the server silently overwrites #1's change.

Locks are a common way to avoid race conditions. Consider the above example with proper locking:

  1. Person #1 sees the incorrect line and starts editing it.
  2. Person #2 also sees the incorrect line, but is unable to edit until Person #1 has pushed their changes to the server.
  3. Person #1's changes are seen by both #1 and #2.
  4. Person #2 decides that #1's changes are adequate, and decides not to edit.

In this scenario, edit access to the document is restricted to one client only. This prevents Person #2 from silently overwriting Person #1's changes. See Wikipedia for further examples.

2338 questions
39
votes
6 answers

Why does Python threading.Condition() notify() require a lock?

My question refers specifically to why it was designed that way, due to the unnecessary performance implication. When thread T1 has this code: cv.acquire() cv.wait() cv.release() and thread T2 has this code: cv.acquire() cv.notify() # requires…
39
votes
9 answers

How to correctly use sync.Cond?

I'm having trouble figuring out how to correctly use sync.Cond. From what I can tell, a race condition exists between locking the Locker and invoking the condition's Wait method. This example adds an artificial delay between the two lines in the…
Nathan Osman
  • 71,149
  • 71
  • 256
  • 361
38
votes
4 answers

Preventing race condition of if-exists-update-else-insert in Entity Framework

I've been reading other questions on how to implement if-exists-insert-else-update semantics in EF, but either I'm not understanding how the answers work, or they are in fact not addressing the issue. A common solution offered is to wrap the work…
Mike Chamberlain
  • 39,692
  • 27
  • 110
  • 158
36
votes
2 answers

How to make sure there is no race condition in MySQL database when incrementing a field?

How to prevent a race condition in MySQL database when two connections want to update the same record? For example, connection 1 wants to increase "tries" counter. And the second connection wants to do the same. Both connections SELECT the "tries"…
bodacydo
  • 75,521
  • 93
  • 229
  • 319
36
votes
6 answers

Can node.js code result in race conditions?

From what I read, race conditions occur when different threads try to change a shared variable, which can result in a value that's not possible with any serial order of execution of those threads. But code in node.js runs in a single thread, so,…
Jatin
  • 14,112
  • 16
  • 49
  • 78
36
votes
3 answers

Adding to a generic dictionary causes IndexOutOfRangeException

I'm using a dictionary inside of some Task. Logically I have set it up so that my Keys will never clash, though sometimes when I am adding to the dictionary I get this Exception. Index was outside the bounds of the array. at…
Austin Harris
  • 1,676
  • 1
  • 17
  • 22
35
votes
4 answers

How can I reproduce the race conditions in this python code reliably?

Context I recently posted a timer class for review on Code Review. I'd had a gut feeling there were concurrency bugs as I'd once seen 1 unit test fail, but was unable to reproduce the failure. Hence my post to code review. I got some great feedback…
doughgle
  • 827
  • 1
  • 9
  • 18
31
votes
4 answers

Race condition: Min and Max range of an integer

I was recently asked this question in an interview. Given the following code, what will be the min and max possible value of the static integer num? import java.util.ArrayList; import java.util.List; public class ThreadTest { private static int…
Anmol Singh Jaggi
  • 8,376
  • 4
  • 36
  • 77
31
votes
3 answers

How does using the try statement avoid a race condition?

When determining whether or not a file exists, how does using the try statement avoid a "race condition"? I'm asking because a highly upvoted answer (update: it was deleted) seems to imply that using os.path.exists() creates an opportunity that…
Honest Abe
  • 8,430
  • 4
  • 49
  • 64
30
votes
3 answers

Can we have race conditions in a single-thread program?

You can find on here a very good explanation about what is a race condition. I have seen recently many people making confusing statements about race conditions and threads. I have learned that race conditions could only occur between threads. But I…
jillro
  • 4,456
  • 2
  • 20
  • 26
29
votes
1 answer

Simulating race conditions in RSpec unit tests

We have an asynchronous task that performs a potentially long-running calculation for an object. The result is then cached on the object. To prevent multiple tasks from repeating the same work, we added locking with an atomic SQL update: UPDATE…
Ian Lesperance
  • 4,961
  • 1
  • 26
  • 28
27
votes
2 answers

Why does ThreadSanitizer report a race with this lock-free example?

I've boiled this down to a simple self-contained example. The main thread enqueues 1000 items, and a worker thread tries to dequeue concurrently. ThreadSanitizer complains that there's a race between the read and the write of one of the elements,…
Cameron
  • 96,106
  • 25
  • 196
  • 225
27
votes
7 answers

Avoiding a Javascript race condition

My users are presented a basically a stripped down version of a spreadsheet. There are textboxes in each row in the grid. When they change a value in a textbox, I'm performing validation on their input, updating the collection that's driving the…
Jeremy Frey
  • 2,334
  • 2
  • 22
  • 26
26
votes
5 answers

Do I need to be concerned with race conditions with asynchronous Javascript?

Suppose I load some Flash movie that I know at some point in the future will call window.flashReady and will set window.flashReadyTriggered = true. Now I have a block of code that I want to have executed when the Flash is ready. I want it to execute…
Steven
  • 17,796
  • 13
  • 66
  • 118
26
votes
2 answers

Is it safe if more git commands are run on the same repo in parallel?

I am interested if it is safe to run things like git push and git commit in parallel (for example in cron jobs, jenkins jobs etc.). Is there some locking mechanism built-in in git so these operations are serialized or this can corrupt the…
user1046334