Questions tagged [priority-inversion]

Priority inversion is a problem that occurs in some systems when a high-priority task (thread or process) is blocked by a low-priority task. If the low-priority task is starved for CPU time by some mid-priority task(s), then the high-priority task effectively is starved also. It is a special concern in embedded systems with hard real-time requirements.

Priority inversion is a problem that occurs in some systems when a high-priority task (i.e., a thread or a process) is blocked by a low-priority task. For example, if the low-priority task holds a mutual exclusion lock, and the high-priority task needs to acquire the same lock before it can make further progress.

If the low-priority task is starved for CPU time by some mid-priority task(s), then the high-priority task effectively is starved also. It's as if its priority has been "inverted" with respect to the mid-priority task(s).

Priority inversion can be a serious problem in real-time applications where the high-priority task may be responsible for fulfilling critical real-time requirements, and also where the scheduler might not implement any kind of fair scheduling policy.

Fair scheduling is often found in desktop and server platforms where many processes compete with one another for resources. Such systems attempt to give each task a "fair share" of the available CPU time, and a scheduling parameter that is called "priority" may actually be more of a suggestion as to how large a particular task's share should be.

In embedded software with hard real-time requirements, it often is the case that all of the tasks in the system cooperate with one another. Granting "fair shares" to competing tasks often is not a design goal, and the scheduler priorities may be absolute (i.e., a low-priority thread is never allowed to run when a higher-priority thread is waiting to run.)

To make matters worse, hard real-time software often runs on small platforms that may have few CPUs (maybe just one). The possibility of priority inversion between a high-priority real-time task and a low-priority background task on such a constrained, embedded platform can pose a significant risk that the device will malfunction.

17 questions
79
votes
11 answers

What is priority inversion?

I've heard the phrase 'priority inversion' in reference to development of operating systems. What exactly is priority inversion? What is the problem it's meant to solve, and how does it solve it?
paxdiablo
  • 854,327
  • 234
  • 1,573
  • 1,953
36
votes
4 answers

After switching to Xcode 14 beta I got this error: QOS_CLASS_USER_INITIATED waiting on a lower QoS thread running at QOS_CLASS_DEFAULT

My app is working well and I didn't get this error on Xcode 13.4, Is it Xcode 14 beta bug or I'm doing some bad threading?! Thread running at QOS_CLASS_USER_INITIATED waiting on a lower QoS thread running at QOS_CLASS_DEFAULT. Investigate ways to…
Vahid
  • 3,352
  • 2
  • 34
  • 42
7
votes
1 answer

Can priority inversion occur in Android

Priority inversion is a problem which can occur during scheduling of threads/processes, due to priorities associated with them. Priority inversion is a problematic scenario in scheduling in which a high priority task is indirectly preempted by a…
user4774371
6
votes
4 answers

Releasing multiple locks without causing priority inversion

Short version: How do I release multiple locks from a single thread, without being preempted halfway through? I have a program which is designed to run on an N-core machine. It consists of one main thread and N worker threads. Each thread (including…
Sneftel
  • 40,271
  • 12
  • 71
  • 104
4
votes
1 answer

Does SCHED_IDLE actually preclude execution on non-idle core?

I'm trying to implement an unprivileged test case for unbounded priority inversion in the absence of priority inheritance mutexes, using SCHED_IDLE. The test works with SCHED_FIFO and different realtime priorities (deadlocking for non-PI mutex,…
R.. GitHub STOP HELPING ICE
  • 208,859
  • 35
  • 376
  • 711
3
votes
1 answer

How does priority ceiling protocol works

In the below scenario how the priority of the task t1 will change when the locks are released, assuming Sem_Take() and Sem_Give() are lock and release method. I understand that using priority ceiling protocol raises the priority of the task as soon…
Anuj Priyadarshi
  • 347
  • 4
  • 16
2
votes
2 answers

FreeRTOS mutex priority inheritance problem if changing priority of task

Here is the scenario I am not sure will be the problem. Foo() { TakeMutex() //some critical code GiveMutex() } Task A priority 5 Task B priority 1 TaskB{ Foo() } TaskA{ Foo() } now in some other task, it may change the priorities of Task A…
Hadi Jaber
  • 145
  • 3
  • 10
2
votes
1 answer

ARM Cortex-M4 Interrupt priorities

I'm using an ARM Cortex-M4 MCU. If I have an interrupt handler for a GPIO at priority 2 and an SPI driver at priority 3 (i.e., lower priority than the GPIO's), and I call a (blocking) SPI read from within the GPIO's interrupt handler, will the SPI…
tosa
  • 411
  • 1
  • 3
  • 23
1
vote
1 answer

POSIX mutex protocol - what exactly does this spec mean?

In this documentation of POSIX mutex protocols - http://pubs.opengroup.org/onlinepubs/9699919799/functions/pthread_mutexattr_getprotocol.html# - we can read following section: While a thread is holding a mutex which has been initialized with the …
Freddie Chopin
  • 8,440
  • 2
  • 28
  • 58
0
votes
0 answers

What is meaning of mutex owner and mutex user?

I have been working with posix threads and mutex since last few years but was not aware of concept of mutex ownership and user. When exploring this document about Priority inheritance and Priority ceiling in posix, the Note section of page put a…
0
votes
0 answers

Is there a way to implement inheritance priority mutex in win32?

I've read the documentation about priority inversion in win32. It seems that the operating system's scheduler handles this case by boosting a waiting thread's priority randomly. Does that mean that there is no deterministic way to know if a mutex…
rweis
  • 3
  • 2
0
votes
1 answer

Can this lead to an issue similar to priority inversion

My project has a practice of reducing the priority of the thread while writing to a file and changing it back after the write operation is complete. This is done because the file write operation could take up important resources, time and restrict…
0
votes
1 answer

Keil RTX priority inheritance with os_mut_wait and short timeout?

Priority Inheritance is a feature of Keil RTX (and others) to prevent priority inversion. If a high priority task is trying to obtain the mutex already obtained by a low level task, priority inheritance would normally cause the low level task to be…
Ant
  • 1,668
  • 2
  • 18
  • 35
0
votes
2 answers

Interruption of process in critical section

In Priority based scheduling, I came across the problem of Priority inversion which is a higher priority process is forced to wait for the lower priority task. One possible scenario is, consider three process L,M,H with order of priority L < M < H…
keerthana
  • 85
  • 1
  • 2
  • 13
0
votes
1 answer

About deadlock in Linux and Windows

Assume you have two processes, P1 and P2. P1 has a high priority, P2 has a low priority. P1 and P2 have one shared semaphore (i.e., they both carry out waits and posts on the same semaphore). The processes can be interleaved in any arbitrary order…
1
2