THIS QUESTION IS SOLVED — can't post an answer to my own question on account of newb status. Had more than one file and was using the wrong file path. User error :-)
I using an email template from MailChimp and I'm substituting a client logo in the title bar for the the gear icon. Here's my logo in the simplified form of a circle with bezelled bottom edge followed by the original gear icon. I'm not allowed to post images yet http://dl.dropbox.com/u/1585739/bze_html_nl/images/header-bg%20with%20gear%20and%2072px%20circle.jpg
Yet when I load it into the browser I get this: Yuk http://dl.dropbox.com/u/1585739/bze_html_nl/images/Yuk.png
The circle and the gear have very similar RGBA values so far as I can see in PS.
I don't think this is any kind of CSS shadow-effect but why is it tearing? (I haven't done much web work before but 30 years of Design and DTP. I'm pretty green re web nuances so far).
Remember this is for an HTML-email so those 'standards' apply :-)
<--! EDIT--> Here is a link to the original "gear" image. It is a .png with alpha, not a .gif btw. Gear http://dl.dropbox.com/u/1585739/bze_html_nl/images/19gear.png My PNG file made in PS with alpha: PNG file http://dl.dropbox.com/u/1585739/bze_html_nl/images/bze-72px.png