Angular change detection runs unexpectedly, based on the expressions order in the view

Question

I am just playing with Angular change detection cycle and I found something that I can't understand.

We have following component's view:

<!-- ver:1 call() was called 3 times -->
<div>
  <p>call(); {{ call() }}</p>
  Name obtained from the API: <b>{{ data.name }}</b>
</div>

<!-- ver:2 call() was called just once -->
<div>
  Name obtained from the API: <b>{{ data.name }}</b>
  <p>call(); {{ call() }}</p>
</div>

So in the ver:1 call() is executed 3 times, we have such order: 1.call() method, 2.render name from the API.

In the ver:2 call() is executed just once and we have such order: 1.render name from the API, 2.call() method.

I think the 'effect' comes from the forked version of the zone.js in the Angular, but I didn't find anything that can explain such behavior in the Angular repo.

Link to the example

score 0 · Answer 1 · answered Jan 20 '23 at 11:10

There is an error in the line {{ data.name }} because data is undefined.

The 2nd version line call(); {{ call() }} is not executed till the data is available, when data gets assigned there are no errors so all the lines in the template get rendered. So it is called only once.

The 1st ver is called multiple times because call(); {{ call() }} is above the error line and gets executed every time there is a change in the data variable or there is a template error.

The 1st time the method is called on rendering the template for the 1st time and it encounters an error at the above line.
The 2nd time, change detection runs when the error occurs in the template (not sure why change detection runs an extra time when there is a template error).
The 3rd time is when the API response is available, data is available, and the complete template is rendered again without any errors.

Angular change detection runs unexpectedly, based on the expressions order in the view

1 Answers1