0

I have been trying to research how I can trigger LONG and EXIT from both crossover and price above security in my backtesting logic without luck and ask now for assistance with my backtesting pine editor code.

I will include some parts of my code so you see what I trying to do.

// add trading pair outside chart data
btc_price = security("BINANCE:BTCUSDT", "D", close)

// compute the indicators ( main chart ETH/USDT ) 
smaInput = input(title="SMA", type=input.integer, defval=1)
indicator1 = sma(close,smaInput)

// compute the indicators BTC
btcsmaInput = input(title="SMABTC", type=input.integer, defval=1)
indicatorbtc = sma(btc_price,btcsmaInput)


// plot the indicators
plot(indicator1, title="Indicator1", color=color.red, linewidth=2)
plot(indicatorbtc, title="Indicator1", color=color.blue, linewidth=2)

What I trying to achieve in pseudo-code: Go Long IF close IS ABOVE indicator1(ETH/USDT) and BTC/USDT price IS ABOVE indicatorbtc Go Exit IF close IS BELOW indicator1(ETH/USDT) or BTC/USDT price close IS BELOW indicatorbtc

Here is my code that I need help with, the code below does not work as I describe it above in the pseudo-code.

// Backtesting Logic
EnterLong =  crossover(close,indicator1) and crossover(btc_price, indicatorbtc)//
ExitLong = crossunder(close,indicator1) or crossunder(btc_price, indicatorbtc) //

Please advice.

Rafal
  • 37
  • 1
  • 11

1 Answers1

2

crossover and crossunder will be true for one bar only and that is when the crossing action becomes true. Your AND condition will fail unless both crossovers happen at the same time.

Here is another idea, use actual values of those variables. So, if btc_price is greater than indicatorbtc, you know that this crossover has already happened. And to trigger your entry function only once, you can use crossover() and the value comparison together.

EnterLong =  (crossover(close,indicator1) or crossover(btc_price, indicatorbtc)) and ((close > indicator1) and (btc_price > indicatorbtc))

So, the first part (crossover(close,indicator1) or crossover(btc_price, indicatorbtc)) will only be true when one of those crossovers happen. Then you can look at the actual values to figure out if the other crossover has happened in the past. That is the ((close > indicator1) and (btc_price > indicatorbtc)) part.

vitruvius
  • 15,740
  • 3
  • 16
  • 26
  • 1
    Thank you so much for taking time to help me out here Baris. This will help me quite much – Rafal Nov 08 '21 at 22:42
  • 1
    Glad I was able to help. Happy coding and come back whenever you have questions. – vitruvius Nov 09 '21 at 07:09
  • One more question. I notice that when I used ((close < indicator1) and (btc_price < indicatorbtc)) it did not follow this rule Exit IF close IS BELOW indicator1(ETH/USDT) or BTC/USDT price close IS BELOW indicatorbtc Is the solution to use OR instead of AND here on the close to get it as mention above?: ExitLong = (crossunder(close,indicator1) or crossunder(btc_price, indicatorbtc)) and ((close < indicator1) or (btc_price < indicatorbtc)) – Rafal Nov 14 '21 at 14:27
  • It should work with the and operator actually. Can you ask a new question? Please add a screenshot where you think it is not working. – vitruvius Nov 14 '21 at 17:35