SwiftUI Setting a State on init

Question

If i don't have an initial value for a @State and set it in the init I get a Fatal Error: EXC_BAD_ACCESS, but only in Release Mode

public struct TestSetStateView: View {
  @State var item:Int
  public init(item: Int) {
    self.item = item
  }
  public var body: some View {
    Text("Hello: \(item)")
  }
}

If i add a default value

public struct TestSetStateView: View {
  @State var item:Int = 0
  public init(item: Int) {
    self.item = item
  }
  public var body: some View {
    Text("Hello: \(item)")
  }
}

and call it with TestSetStateView(item: 8) it shows "Hello: 0"

If I move that to onAppear

public struct TestSetStateView: View {
  @State var item:Int = 0
  let firstItem: Int
  public init(item: Int) {
    firstItem = item
  }
  public var body: some View {
    Text("Hello: \(item)")
      .onAppear(perform: {
        item = firstItem
      })
  }
}

and call it with TestSetStateView(item: 8) it shows "Hello: 8" which is great

or if i use the _ wrapper:

public struct TestSetStateView: View {
  @State var item:Int
  public init(item: Int) {
    _item = State(initialValue: item)
  }
  public var body: some View {
    Text("Hello: \(item)")
  }
}

and call it with TestSetStateView(item: 8) it shows "Hello: 8", which is also great!

I'm just not sure what's happening, why can i use item = firstItem in onAppear and not in init. I sort of understand that the _ uses the @State wrapper but why don't we have to use the in onAppear. Also not sure why the error in the first example only happens in release.

Does this answer your question? [How could I initialize the @State variable in the init function in SwiftUI?](https://stackoverflow.com/questions/58758370/how-could-i-initialize-the-state-variable-in-the-init-function-in-swiftui) — Phil Dukhov, Sep 29 '21 at 15:48

score 1 · Answer 1 · answered Sep 29 '21 at 13:23

This code:

public struct TestSetStateView: View {
  @State var item:Int
  public init(item: Int) {
    _item = State(initialValue: item)
  }
  public var body: some View {
    Text("Hello: \(item)")
  }
}

is correct. Until a State variable is initialized, you can't set the underlying value directly. Remember, State is a property wrapper. The type of @State var item is not Int, it is a State that happens to contain an Int. It could just as easily contain a Double or a String. Trying to set a State with a value of Int makes as much sense as setting a String with an Int. You have a type mismatch. Frankly, the compiler should have screamed that you can't do that, but instead you get a crash.

Once the State var is initialized, it knows how to handle changing its underlying wrapped value directly. You can also initialize it directly elsewhere. Even the code: _item refers to the wrapped value, and not the state itself. Why they chose different semantics in the State property wrapper initializer, I don't know. But they did, and excluded us from using the convenience init() of the @State declaration in our view inits.

SwiftUI Setting a State on init

1 Answers1