Not Exists giving zero rows

Question

I have read many answers related to this and all are saying both works almost same except in the case of null values ,and not in works for a single column.

The task is to find each account number that has never been assigned to any line item in invoice_line_items table:

Correct query is:

SELECT 
    account_number, account_description
FROM
    general_ledger_accounts gl
WHERE
    NOT EXISTS( SELECT 
            account_number
        FROM
            invoice_line_items
        WHERE
            gl.account_number = account_number);

And if I remove gl.account_number = account_number it is returning zero rows.

I want to know : 1 ) Why there is a need for the statement gl.account_number = account_number in the subquery.
2 ) How the selection process is different in Not In and Not Exists.

I don't fully follow your question. Your code is not different at all from `not exists`. — Gordon Linoff, May 02 '20 at 02:55
@GordonLinoff I wanna know why should I use the gl.account_number = account_number in the subquery? — Brijesh Joshi, May 02 '20 at 02:59

score 0 · Accepted Answer · answered May 02 '20 at 02:58

You should write this using qualified column references throughout the query. Also, the select in the subquery doesn't matter so I usually use 1:

SELECT gl.account_number, gl.account_description
FROM general_ledger_accounts gl
WHERE NOT EXISTS (SELECT 1
                  FROM invoice_line_items ili
                  WHERE gl.account_number = ili.account_number
                 );

The subquery is a correlated subquery because the where clause connects the inner subquery on ili to the outer subquery on gl. Conceptually, this is going through each account in gl. The where clause evaluates to true when no rows match a particular account_number.

This is similar to NOT IN, except -- as you yourself point out -- when the NOT IN subquery returns NULL for any row.

@BrijeshJoshi . . . This is will not be a correlated subquery. The outer query will return either all rows (if there are any rows in `ili`) or no rows at all if there a no rows. — Gordon Linoff, May 02 '20 at 03:08

Not Exists giving zero rows

1 Answers1