There are a couple problems I can see in the example code, but I think the main issue regarding the context
is that you're storing a Promise as context.permalink
, not the actual result of the method call. In order to store the result, you should use the await
keyword before calling the method (app.client.chat.getPermalink(...)
).
I've revised the code you shared here, and I'll explain the modifications below.
const { App } = require('@slack/bolt');
const token = process.env.SLACK_BOT_TOKEN
const app = new App({
signingSecret: process.env.SLACK_SIGNING_SECRET,
token,
});
// Users who should be notified when certain messages are heard
let userzArray = ["D010Q34TQL9", "UVBBD8989"];
// Conversation IDs corresponding to the users in the array above. This variable will be set automatically when the app starts.
let conversationsToNotify;
// Match messages that include the text 'jira' or '@rdu_qa'
app.message(/jira|@rdu_qa/, async ({ message, client }) => {
// Match the messages that are in the specified channel
if (message.channel === 'C0109KMQCFQ') {
try {
// Get a permalink to this message
const permalinkResult = await client.chat.getPermalink({
channel: message.channel,
message_ts: message.ts,
});
// Send a message to each user containing the permalink for this message
await Promise.all(conversationsToNotify.map((conversationId) => {
return client.chat.postMessage({
channel: conversationId,
blocks: [
{
type: 'section',
text: {
type: 'mrkdwn',
text: `>>> ${payload.text}`,
},
fields: [
{
type: 'mrkdwn',
text: `posted by <@${message.user}>`,
},
{
type: 'mrkdwn',
text: `in <#${message.channel}>`,
},
{
type:'mrkdwn',
text: `<Original|${permalinkResult.permalink}>`,
},
],
},
{
type: 'divider'
},
],
});
}));
} catch (error) {
console.error(error);
}
}
});
async function convertUsersToConversations(input) {
return Promise.all(input.map((id) => {
// For all IDs that seem like user IDs, convert them to a DM conversation ID
if (id.startsWith('U')) {
return app.client.conversations.open({
token,
users: id,
})
.then((result) => result.channel.id);
}
// For all IDs that don't seem to belong to a user, return them as is
return id;
}));
});
(async () => {
// Start the app
conversationsToNotify = await convertUsersToConversations(userzArray);
await app.start(process.env.PORT || 3000);
console.log('⚡️ Bolt app is running!');
})();
- I've removed the initialization of a new
WebClient
object. In Bolt v1.6.0 and later, there is a client
argument available in listeners and middleware which you can use to call Web API methods instead. The advantage of using the client
argument is that you don't need to read the token from the context and pass it as an argument for each method call on your own, Bolt will find the right token for you.
- Instead of using the
app.event('message', ...)
method to listen for message events, I've changed to using app.message(...)
. The latter works mostly the same, but has one more advantage: you can pass a pattern to match the text of a message as the first argument (before the listener function): app.message(pattern, ...)
. That helps remove some of the conditions inside the listener. Instead of using just the two string variables jira_text
and @rdu_qa
, I've combined them in a single regular expression that matches when either of those values is seen in the text: /jira|@rdu_qa/
.
- Instead of using middleware to find the permalink of a message, I've moved that code into the listener. Middleware should be used to reuse code across multiple listeners (or global middleware to reuse code across all listeners). In your example, it doesn't seem like the code to find the permalink is being reused, but if you do use this in many listeners, it should be relatively easy to extract. Another advantage is now the logic only runs after the pattern was matched, so you're not making these calls for every single message that the bot sees in all channels that it is a member of (this is much better for performance).
- Use
Promise.all()
to collect the Promises of each call to chat.postMessage
into one promise. Currently, you're using userzArray.forEach(...)
, which doesn't return anything. So then using await
on that value will immediately resolve, and doesn't really do anything useful. What we need to do is collect each of the Promises and wait for them to all complete. This is what Promise.all()
does. We just need an array of Promises to pass in, which we can get by simply changing userzArray.forEach()
to userzArray.map()
.
- There's a problem with the way you're calling
chat.postMessage
. You're trying to use Slackbot to send those messages, but that's not recommended because users are less likely to understand where that message is coming from. Instead, you should send this message as a DM from your bot user. In order to do that, you need a conversation ID, not a user ID, for each user you want to send this notification to. One of the items in userzArray
is already a DM conversation ID (it starts with a D
), but the other is not. In order to make this work consistently, I've created the conversationsToNotify
array which contains the conversation IDs for each user after calling conversations.open
to create a DM. Now in the code, you'll see conversationsToNotify.map()
instead of userzArray.map()
. Your Slack app will now need the im:write
and chat:write
permission scopes (don't forget to reinstall once you add scopes). Looking up the conversation IDs will slow down your app from starting up if the number of users in the array gets larger. My recommendation would be to save the conversation IDs in your code (or in a database) instead of the user IDs. This will ensure a consistently fast start up time for your app.
- There's an opportunity to do even better. What happens when the first call to
chat.postMessage
fails? The way I've written the code above, the error would be logged to the console, but later if the second call fails, there's no way to know. That's because Promise.all()
returns a promise that will reject as soon as any one of the promises rejects, and then ignores what happens afterwards. If you're using Node v12.9.0 or greater, I would recommend using Promise.allSettled()
instead (which would require a few changes in your catch
clause as well).
- General cleanup:
- Use
message
argument in the listener everywhere instead of payload
argument. These are actually the same value when dealing with message
events. payload
is mostly only useful in middleware that handle several kinds of events (action, event, view, shortcut, etc) so that there's one way to refer to all of their payloads.
- Move
userzArray
outside the listener, and make it a constant. There's no point in redeclaring it inside the listener each time it runs, and it doesn't change.
- I added a function to convert from user IDs to conversation IDs (
convertUsersToConversations
). This function is called before the app is started to avoid a race condition where the an incoming message is handled before the app knows which channels to notify.
- Formatted the text content of the message as quoted text, formatted the channel mention, and formatted the permalink. One improvement I'd also recommend is to use a context block to show the message author's name and avatar image.