RadioButtonList inside UpdatePanel inside Repeater, Can I?

Question

I have a repeater with a RadioButtonList inside the ItemTemplate, but when the RadioButtonList.OnSelectedIndexChanged event fires it generates a full postback. What have I done wrong in my code below? How can I get the OnSelectedIndexChanged to generate an Async Postback?

<asp:UpdatePanel runat="server" ID="UpdatePanel2">
    <ContentTemplate>
        <asp:Repeater ID="Repeater1" runat="server" DataSourceID="sqlOptions">
            <ItemTemplate>
                <asp:UpdatePanel runat="server" ID="pnlA">
                    <ContentTemplate>
                        <strong>
                            <%# Eval("Name") %></strong><br />
                        <asp:RadioButtonList ID="RadioButtonList1" 
                             DataSourceID="sqlOptionValues" runat="server"
                             DataTextField="id" DataValueField="Id" AutoPostBack="true" 
                             OnSelectedIndexChanged="LoadPrice"
                             ValidationGroup="options" />
                        <asp:RequiredFieldValidator ID="RequiredFieldValidator1" 
                             ForeColor="Red" runat="server" 
                             ControlToValidate="RadioButtonList1" 
                             ErrorMessage="Required Field" 
                             ValidationGroup="options" />
                        <asp:SqlDataSource ID="sqlOptionValues" runat="server" 
                             ConnectionString="<%$ ConnectionStrings:
                                 ConnectionString6 %>"
                             SelectCommand='<%# "SELECT DISTINCT OptionValue.Name,
                                 OptionValue.Id FROM CombinationDetail 
                                 INNER JOIN OptionValue 
                                 ON CombinationDetail.OptionValueId = OptionValue.Id 
                                 WHERE (OptionValue.OptionId =" + 
                                 Eval("Id") + ")" %>'>
                        </asp:SqlDataSource>
                        <br />
                    </ContentTemplate>
                </asp:UpdatePanel>
            </ItemTemplate>
        </asp:Repeater>
    </ContentTemplate>
</asp:UpdatePanel>

Many thanks for any help :)

RadioButtonList inside an updatePanel inside a Repeater inside an updatePanel... are you serious? — IrishChieftain, May 05 '11 at 21:06
Hi, I have updated my answer, please take a look. It is way better than what I initially suggested. — MikeTeeVee, May 24 '11 at 21:29

score 12 · Accepted Answer · edited May 23 '17 at 11:44

This is a real-world use case. I have a page with Repeaters, Ajax Accordions inside of other Accordions, Update Panels inside other Update panels, you name it. The page works great, except when I want to update one of the Accordion panels with my RadioButtonList (RBL). Even with the RBL inside an update panel, it causes a postback of the entire page. I tried everything. I finally realized it wasn't me when I noticed my buttons would work just fine. I figure it must be a bug in either the framework or the Ajax Control Toolkit. I did find people reference this link all over the web (http://blog.smarx.com/posts/the-case-of-the-radiobuttonlist-half-trigger.aspx), but this link from 2007 is dead now and probably no longer applicable, so that's no help.

What I ended up doing was going with what works - that submit button. All I did was add an onclick attribute to the RBL to call a hidden button. Now you don't want to set the button to Visible=false because then the button won't appear in the generated markup. Instead, set the button's style to display:none; so that no one will see this hack, because yes, that's what this workaround is - it's a hack, but simple and just as effective as what you'd expect. Don't forget to remove the Autopostback="True" from your RBL.

CAVEAT: Because I'm using a hacked button for the onclick event, it's possible for the user to click in the area of the RBL, but not actually select an item. When this happens, our onclick triggers an AsyncPostBack and the codebehind logic will be processed, so please keep that in mind. To give you an idea of what I mean: all the Page_Load() events will be called, but rbl_Questions_SelectedIndexChanged() won't be if they happen to click in the area of the RBL without actually selecting an item. For my purposes this causes no issues in my logic and has no effect on the user.

Here's the Code:

Somewhere In the .Aspx Page:

<asp:UpdatePanel ID="UpdatePanel1" runat="server">  
    <ContentTemplate>

        <asp:RadioButtonList ID="rbl_Questions" runat="server"
            OnSelectedIndexChanged="rbl_Questions_SelectedIndexChanged">
        </asp:RadioButtonList>

        <asp:Button ID="btn_rbl_Questions" runat="server" style="display:none;"/>

        <asp:Label ID="lbl_Result" runat="server" Text="" Visible="false">
        </asp:Label>
    </ContentTemplate>  
</asp:UpdatePanel>

In the Page_Load() event:

protected void Page_Load(object sender, EventArgs e)
{
    if (IsPostBack == false)
    {
        //Instead of using the AutoPostback of the RBL, use this instead.
        rbl_Questions.Attributes.Add("onclick",
            "document.getElementById('"
            + btn_rbl_Questions.ClientID
            + "').click();");
        //Bind your RBL to a DataSource, add items programmatically,
        //  or add them in the aspx markup.
    }
}

In the rbl_Questions_SelectedIndexChanged() event:

protected void rbl_Questions_SelectedIndexChanged(object sender, EventArgs e)
{
    //Your code here.
    //My code unhid the lbl_Result control and set its text value.
}

Update 05/24/2011

The above "hack" is no longer necessary (I am leaving it above since this was marked as the answer by the author). I have found the best way to do this, thanks to this SO Answer:
Updatepanel gives full postback instead of asyncpostback

The code is much simpler now, just remove what I put in the Page_Load() method and remove the Button I used in the Aspx page and add ClientIDMode="AutoID" and AutoPostBack="True" to the control you want the UpdatePanel to capture.

Somewhere In the .Aspx Page:

<asp:UpdatePanel ID="UpdatePanel1" runat="server">  
    <ContentTemplate>

        <asp:RadioButtonList ID="rbl_Questions" runat="server"
            ClientIDMode="AutoID" AutoPostBack="true"
            OnSelectedIndexChanged="rbl_Questions_SelectedIndexChanged">
        </asp:RadioButtonList>

        <asp:Label ID="lbl_Result" runat="server" Text="" Visible="false">
        </asp:Label>
    </ContentTemplate>  
</asp:UpdatePanel>

MS changed how ClientID's are generated in .net 4.0 from "AutoID" to "Predictable" and I guess the ScriptManager or UpdatePanel's weren't updated correctly to use it. I can't find documentation on why that is anywhere or if it was left that way by design.

Wish I could +2 this one. +1 for the hack making me laugh and +1 for the sane way to do it! — Nicholas Murray, Oct 03 '12 at 08:37
I would suggest putting the proper solution at the top of your answer, so people dont have to read through the unnecessary hacky part which is probably only left for history reasons anyway. — magnattic, Jan 21 '14 at 16:05

score 1 · Answer 2 · answered May 05 '11 at 21:18

1

I seriously don't miss winforms.

Try this:

<asp:UpdatePanel runat="server" UpdateMode="Conditional" ID="pnlA">

You'll also need to setup

<Triggers>
 //radio buttons
</Triggers>

Not sure how you'll do that since it's a dynamically built list.

answered May 05 '11 at 21:18

Jack Marchetti

15,536
14
81
117

RadioButtonList inside UpdatePanel inside Repeater, Can I?

2 Answers2

Update 05/24/2011