You won't be able to replay the recorded test OpenID assumes correlation - the process of extracting dynamic parameters from the response using JMeter PostProcessors, saving them into JMeter Variables and replacing hard-coded recorded values with the aforementioned variables.
No one can provide you "help" as there are too many possible providers and too many configuration options even given single provider.
General recommendation is:
- Record your test plan 2 times. Make sure to have View Results Tree listener under the HTTP(S) Test Script Recorder
- Inspect recorded request details and identify the values which are dynamic
- Configure JMeter to extract dynamic values from the response and substitute the request parameters which are different
- Carefully inspect HTTP Header Manager elements as dynamic values might also live there
- Add HTTP Cookie Manager to your Test Plan
- You might also find How to Load Test OpenId Secured Websites
guide easier to read/understand.