8

I'm having a problem that, at this moment, I don't even know how to investigate properly. Any recommendations on how I can get more information are welcome and appreciated.

My company sells a product with a WinXP PC at its core. One of the product's tasks is being able to start a video player on demand -- VLC, in this case. (To be specific, VLC 0.8.6d; it's several years out of date, but upgrading is problematic for a few reasons.) The application responsible for starting the player and performing many, many other tasks is written in Java.

I have a test rig sitting next to my desk. It used to work just fine. But for some reason, it now gives a "Send Error Report" window when the Java app tries to start VLC: "VLC media player has encountered a problem and needs to close...." You know the one.

Clearly, I've done something that buggered things up. Problem is, I know neither what it could be nor how I would go about fixing it.

Stuff I know:

  • It's not a code bug. I run the same software on my development desktop machine, and it doesn't have this issue.
  • It's not the VLC install, nor is it a malformed video file. When I capture the command used to start it from Java and manually enter that command from a "cmd" window, it works fine.
  • It's not that sneaky bastich bug where Java punishes you if you don't manually drain STDERR and STDOUT when making a system call. I've got that covered.
  • I'm not getting any error messages or output when it fails; it just fails and gives me that pop-up window.

I'm stumped. Recommendations for either what it could be or how I can figure out what it is are very welcome.

BlairHippo
  • 9,502
  • 10
  • 54
  • 78
  • 1
    I am not very sure as you are able to run the vlc from the command prompt, but still have a look at this article ( http://techdows.com/2009/04/how-to-fixvlc-media-player-has.html ). I am upping your question (maybe someone else could solve it). – Favonius Jan 28 '11 at 04:11
  • It might be that your Java program doesn't have the sufficient privileges needed to run VLC with the required flags? Please check if your program is using the same vlcrc file as you are. – dirbacke Feb 07 '11 at 10:00

3 Answers3

1

Well, I’m not familiar with java and VLC, but I would do the following things:

  1. Check that you have identical java virtual machines in both of your desktops. Just in case…
  2. Check the process’s environment variables. They depend on parent process. Maybe VLC uses some of them.
  3. Try to debug crashing with native debugger like WinDbg. Perhaps the call stack will give you more ideas.

Good luck!

Eugene
  • 3,335
  • 3
  • 36
  • 44
0

My suggestions:

  1. Create a simple java app that just launches VLC
  2. Use your app to launch a simple command line windows program
  3. Use your app to launch a complex program
  4. Check to see if there is a memory constraint issue. Is VLC getting too little memory to run?

This really sounds like a memory/environment issue.

Pat
  • 5,761
  • 5
  • 34
  • 50
0

A number of things I would try

  1. Make Sure both test and development machines are identical in every respect, the operating syste(if possible installed from same OS Disk), same JVM version, same memory allocation to JVM (you know those -X-ms stuffs). My fear is not with Java/JVM per se, it is with windows.
  2. Make sure you can lunch for example Notepad from a Java app, and then something like Windows Media Player or MS Word.
  3. Try and launch other versions of VLC to see if it is a VLC version problem.
  4. Finally try and wipe the test box and re-install it(with Windows, you can never tell, a fresh installation might just do it!!)
Akintayo Olusegun
  • 917
  • 1
  • 10
  • 20