7

I read a lot about Base Translation in Xcode but some parts seem far away from being intuitive or correct.

localizable.strings

For this question I assume to have an App with base translation and CFBundleDevelopmentRegion = en.

Expected behavior

1) What is inside base translation of localizable.strings?

It should be english. So all Apps with a missing translation should fall back to base (=english).

2) What do new translations base upon?

When I export xliff files for translation they should source on base translation.

3) Is english needed beside base which is english?

I should not need an english translation, since base is english

Actual behavior

1) I don't see a use for base translation of localizable.strings. It is not used as fallback. It is not used for new translations.

2) xliffs for new languages depend on CFBundleDevelopmentRegion, so in this case the english translation. E.g: I export xliff for fr -> I get a file which has english translation to work out french translation.

3) To have xliff not to depend on the key in NSLocalizedString I need to have a localizable.strings in english.

This ends me up in the following.

1) I don't have a base localization for localizable.strings

2+3) Instead I need a localization for english and for that I need english as supported language beside base.

XIB/Storyboard

In XIB/Storyboard it is different! I understand that base here could be something abstract like "Header Label" or "username" since I can't describe that otherwise.

All together

I don't need basefor anything. Instead I need the language of CFBundleDevelopmentRegion plus each localization I need additionally as translations.

Questions

1) Is base a concrete language (e.g. english) or an abstract description (e.g. "username")?

2) Do I need the CFBundleDevelopmentRegion as a concrete localization beside base?

beseder
  • 1,352
  • 2
  • 15
  • 25
  • Well this is quite nice, no answer to such an essential, thouroghly presented question since more than three years. Why is that? – LukeSideWalker Oct 23 '20 at 20:56
  • Thanks @LukeSideWalker, I would still appreciate any answers on that as I still see it open :-) – beseder Oct 27 '20 at 12:43

0 Answers0