I think QQuickImageProvider is the proper way.
Also, I think you can use the word 'overkill' if you know exactly how the Qt internals work. Otherwise it's just guessing.
AFAIK there is a complex caching system of images (and other data) underneath, so once an image pixmap is loaded (and doesn't change) data retrieval is immediate. So no overkill at all, since in any case at some point you need to load those QImage, but just once.
I believe a QQuickImageProvider provides pointers to the cached data, and not the whole rasterized data every time. Moreover blitting operations are nowadays performed with hardware accelerations, so it's a single operation taking a fraction of millisecond.
In other words you end up having:
- give me image with url "image://xyz"
- Qt looks up in the cache and returns the data pointer or performs a full load of the image if not found
- the QML renderer passes the data array to OpenGL
- one single blit operation (microseconds) and you have it on screen