NHibernate HiLo generator generates duplicate Id's

Question

I have an application running on nHibernate v4.0.4.4000 - it is running in production on three seperate webservers. For ID-generation, I'm using the default HiLo implementation (unique id across tables).

Sometimes, it generates duplicate Id's when saving new entities with the following stack-trace:

at NHibernate.AdoNet.SqlClientBatchingBatcher.DoExecuteBatch(IDbCommand ps)
at NHibernate.AdoNet.AbstractBatcher.ExecuteBatchWithTiming(IDbCommand ps)
at NHibernate.AdoNet.AbstractBatcher.ExecuteBatch()
at NHibernate.AdoNet.AbstractBatcher.PrepareCommand(CommandType type, SqlString sql, SqlType[] parameterTypes)
at NHibernate.AdoNet.AbstractBatcher.PrepareBatchCommand(CommandType type, SqlString sql, SqlType[] parameterTypes)
at NHibernate.Persister.Entity.AbstractEntityPersister.Insert(Object id, Object[] fields, Boolean[] notNull, Int32 j, SqlCommandInfo sql, Object obj, ISessionImplementor session)
at NHibernate.Persister.Entity.AbstractEntityPersister.Insert(Object id, Object[] fields, Object obj, ISessionImplementor session)
at NHibernate.Action.EntityInsertAction.Execute()
at NHibernate.Engine.ActionQueue.Execute(IExecutable executable)
at NHibernate.Engine.ActionQueue.ExecuteActions(IList list)
at NHibernate.Engine.ActionQueue.ExecuteActions()
at NHibernate.Event.Default.AbstractFlushingEventListener.PerformExecutions(IEventSource session)
at NHibernate.Event.Default.DefaultFlushEventListener.OnFlush(FlushEvent event)
at NHibernate.Impl.SessionImpl.Flush()
at Xena.Database.Main.Listeners.Strategies.CreateEntityAuditTrailStrategy.Execute(Object criteria) in K:\Projects\Xena\WorkDir\src\Xena.Database.Main\Listeners\Strategies\CreateEntityAuditTrailStrategy.cs:line 41
at Xena.Domain.Rules.Strategies.StrategyExtensions.Execute[TCriteria](IEnumerable`1 strategies, TCriteria criteria) in K:\Projects\Xena\WorkDir\src\Xena.Domain\Rules\Strategies\RelayStrategy.cs:line 55
at NHibernate.Action.EntityInsertAction.PostInsert()
at NHibernate.Action.EntityInsertAction.Execute()
at NHibernate.Engine.ActionQueue.Execute(IExecutable executable)
at NHibernate.Engine.ActionQueue.ExecuteActions(IList list)
at NHibernate.Engine.ActionQueue.ExecuteActions()
at NHibernate.Event.Default.AbstractFlushingEventListener.PerformExecutions(IEventSource session)
at NHibernate.Event.Default.DefaultAutoFlushEventListener.OnAutoFlush(AutoFlushEvent event)
at NHibernate.Impl.SessionImpl.AutoFlushIfRequired(ISet`1 querySpaces)
at NHibernate.Impl.SessionImpl.List(CriteriaImpl criteria, IList results)
at NHibernate.Impl.CriteriaImpl.List(IList results)
at NHibernate.Impl.CriteriaImpl.UniqueResult[T]()
at Xena.Web.EntityUpdaters.LedgerPostPreviewUpdater.TryCreateNewFiscalEntity(ISession session, FiscalSetup fiscalSetup, LedgerPostPreview& entity, IEnumerable`1& errors) in K:\Projects\Xena\WorkDir\src\Xena.Web\EntityUpdaters\LedgerPostPreviewUpdater.cs:line 52
at Xena.Web.SecurityContext.<>c__DisplayClass8_0`1.<TrySaveUpdate>b__0(ISession session, TEntity& entity, IEnumerable`1& errors) in K:\Projects\Xena\WorkDir\src\Xena.Web\SecurityContext.cs:line 235
at Xena.Web.SecurityContext.<>c__DisplayClass41_0`1.<TrySave>b__0(ITransaction tx) in K:\Projects\Xena\WorkDir\src\Xena.Web\SecurityContext.cs:line 815
at Xena.Web.SecurityContext.TryWrapInTransaction[T](Func`2 action, T& result, IEnumerable`1& errors, Boolean alwaysCommit) in K:\Projects\Xena\WorkDir\src\Xena.Web\SecurityContext.cs:line 804
at Xena.Web.SecurityContext.TrySave[TEntity](IEntityUpdater`1 entityUpdater, EntityCreate`1 create) in K:\Projects\Xena\WorkDir\src\Xena.Web\SecurityContext.cs:line 812
at Xena.Web.SecurityContext.TrySaveUpdate[TEntity](IFiscalEntityUpdater`1 entityUpdater) in K:\Projects\Xena\WorkDir\src\Xena.Web\SecurityContext.cs:line 236
at Xena.Web.Api.XenaFiscalApiController.WrapSave[TEntity,TDto](IFiscalEntityUpdater`1 updater, Func`2 get, Action`2 postGet) in K:\Projects\Xena\WorkDir\src\Xena.Web\Api\Abstract\XenaFiscalApiController.cs:line 35
at Xena.Web.Api.ApiLedgerPostPreviewController.Post(LedgerPostPreviewDto ledgerPostPreview) in K:\Projects\Xena\WorkDir\src\Xena.Web\Api\ApiLedgerPostPreviewController.cs:line 79
at lambda_method(Closure , Object , Object[] )
at System.Web.Http.Controllers.ReflectedHttpActionDescriptor.ActionExecutor.<>c__DisplayClass10.<GetExecutor>b__9(Object instance, Object[] methodParameters)
at System.Web.Http.Controllers.ReflectedHttpActionDescriptor.ExecuteAsync(HttpControllerContext controllerContext, IDictionary`2 arguments, CancellationToken cancellationToken)
--- End of stack trace from previous location where exception was thrown ---
at System.Runtime.ExceptionServices.ExceptionDispatchInfo.Throw()
at System.Runtime.CompilerServices.TaskAwaiter.HandleNonSuccessAndDebuggerNotification(Task task)
at System.Web.Http.Controllers.ApiControllerActionInvoker.<InvokeActionAsyncCore>d__0.MoveNext()
--- End of stack trace from previous location where exception was thrown ---
at System.Runtime.ExceptionServices.ExceptionDispatchInfo.Throw()
at System.Runtime.CompilerServices.TaskAwaiter.HandleNonSuccessAndDebuggerNotification(Task task)
at System.Runtime.CompilerServices.TaskAwaiter`1.GetResult()
at System.Web.Http.Controllers.ActionFilterResult.<ExecuteAsync>d__2.MoveNext()
--- End of stack trace from previous location where exception was thrown ---
at System.Runtime.ExceptionServices.ExceptionDispatchInfo.Throw()
at System.Runtime.CompilerServices.TaskAwaiter.HandleNonSuccessAndDebuggerNotification(Task task)
at System.Web.Http.Filters.AuthorizationFilterAttribute.<ExecuteAuthorizationFilterAsyncCore>d__2.MoveNext()
--- End of stack trace from previous location where exception was thrown ---
at System.Runtime.ExceptionServices.ExceptionDispatchInfo.Throw()
at System.Runtime.CompilerServices.TaskAwaiter.HandleNonSuccessAndDebuggerNotification(Task task)
at System.Runtime.CompilerServices.TaskAwaiter`1.GetResult()
at System.Web.Http.Dispatcher.HttpControllerDispatcher.<SendAsync>d__1.MoveNext()

And the following message:

Message=Violation of PRIMARY KEY constraint 'PK_LedgerPostPreview'. Cannot insert duplicate key in object 'dbo.LedgerPostPreview'. The duplicate key value is (94873244).
The statement has been terminated.

The SessionFactory is set to use SnapshotIsolation, the DB is set at compability level 2008 (100)

As far as I can tell, the updating of the hilo value is running in a transaction separate from the "normal" transactions (I've tried causing an exception - the hilo value is not rolled back (which makes sense)).

According to the NHibernate profiler, the SQL run against the server for hilo values is:

Reading high value: 
select next_hi
from   hibernate_unique_key with (updlock, rowlock)
Updating high value: 
update hibernate_unique_key
set    next_hi = 5978 /* @p0 */
where  next_hi = 5977 /* @p1 - next_hi */

What am I missing? Shouldn't the HiLo guard against duplicates?

EDIT: The duplicate IDs are not happening only on one table, but in the tables with very frequent inserts and deletions. The above code was the simplest among the suspects and is extremely simple - it only .Get() a parent to check it is there and then creates and calls .Save() on the new entity along with an audit trail row (which uses the PostInsert eventlistener in nHibernate).

EDIT2: Id-Mapping for the above type (used across all entities):

    public static void MapId<TMapping, TType>(this TMapping mapping)
        where TMapping : ClassMapping<TType>
        where TType : class,IHasId
    {
        mapping.Id(m => m.Id, m => m.Generator(Generators.HighLow, g => g.Params(new { max_lo = 100 })));
    }

The weird part is that (due to @Dexions comment) when I check both the audit trail and the table - nothing has been persisted. The code used to persist is as follows:

using (var tx = Session.BeginTransaction())
{
    try
    {
        var voucherPreview = Session.Get<VoucherPreview>(voucherPreviewId); //Parent
        var postPreview = //Factory create with the voucherPreview;
        var index = Session.QueryOver<LedgerPostPreview>()
            .Where(lpp => lpp.VoucherPreview == voucherPreview)
            .SelectList(l => l.SelectMax(lpp => lpp.Index))
            .SingleOrDefault<int>() + 1
        postPreview.Index = index;
        // Set a few other properties and check validity
        Session.SaveOrUpdate(postPreview);
    }
    catch(Exception ex)
    {
        //Errorhandling leading to the above stacktrace
    }
}

Answer 1

I figured out the problem. It turns out, it had nothing to do with the Id.

As a part of the insert statement, we update a secondary table that controls a number series. The problem occurs if that secondary table experiences a snapshot isolation fault - since everything is handled in SQLCommandSets internally in nHibernate - the error bubbles up the chain with a faulty description.

Answer 2

Given the comment chain on the question, IMHO there are 2 possible cases that I can think of at the moment.

You either misshandle nhibernate sessions and you got a hidden race condition going on when the actual ID generation happens on a given instance (because ID sequencing on the database is transactionally isolated). This assumes that the same application instance successfully inserted { ID=123 } and then attempted to insert an other object with { ID=123 }. You can trace inserts back to application instances to verify the duplication of inserts happens on the same instance. I am not very sure if this scenario is actually plausible on the whole chain of NHibernate pipeline but ISession is not thread-safe (and that is a known fact). You do say that this has been running for 4 years now (although you don't mention if the bug has been there as long), so maybe a recent commit introduced this behaviour (a collection.AsParallel() would be enough to trigger it I believe) ?

---

A different angle on the problem assumes that an already inserted object was loaded and then detached from the ISession, but got re-attached (by design or by accident) on a (same/different) ISession which then promptly attempted to insert the object. This can happen and a hypothetical scenario could be

1. var entity123 = Get(123)
2. var entity123 = entity123.Clone() or ISession.Evict(entity123).
3. somewhere along the line you call SaveOrUpdate(entity123) (or even worse for tracing you add it on a referenced collection with cascade-save rules)
4. NHibernate sees an an-managed object with an identifier in place, tries to insert it.

In some earlier version of NHibernate I did see this behaviour with non-identity inserts.

The above could also happen with a bad/dumb factory method that also copies the identifier.

To trace this check if the insertion SQL parameters (for log4net that would be a NHibernate.SQL entry with debug, although I think the NHibernate profiler will expose this as well) match the existing row's column values. If they match exactly then something like the above may be happening. If they match partially, maybe you make partial copies of entities and it mistankenly copies the ID as well.

Answer 3

what if you just changed to:

postPreview.Index = index+1;