From testing, it seems like trying to convert both IDNs and regular domain names 'just works' - eg, if the input doesn't need to be changed punycode will just return the input.
punycode.toASCII('lancôme.com');
returns:
'xn--lancme-lxa.com'
And
punycode.toASCII('apple.com');
returns:
'apple.com'
This looks great, but is it specified anywhere? Can I safely convert everything to punycode?
That is correct. If you look at how the procedure for converting unicode strings to ascii punycode, the process only alters any non-ascii character. Since regular domains cannot contain non-ascii characters, if your conversor is correctly implemented, it will never transform any pure-ascii string.
You can read more about how unicode is converted to punycode here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punycode
Punycode is specified in RFC 3492: https://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc3492.txt, and it clearly says:
"Basic code point segregation" is a very simple and efficient encoding for basic code points occurring in the extended string: they are simply copied all at once.
Therefore, if your extended string is made of basic code points, it will just be copied without change.
