Order of Route in Symfony

Question

I Use Symfony 3, And I Want to understand How symfony chouses the Route.

I have 3 routes, 2 in routing.yml and 1 in annotation. this is my code:

app/config/routing.yml

app:
    resource: "@AppBundle/Controller/"
    type:     annotation

hello:
    path: "hello/{firstName}"
    defaults: {_controller: AppBundle:Default:rotta,firstName: "route1"}

hello_name:
    path: "hello/{firstName}"
    defaults:  {_controller: AppBundle:Default:rotta, firstName: "route2"}

src/AppBundle/Controller/DefaultController.php

/**
 * @Route("hello/{firstName}", name="hello", defaults={"firstName" = "Annotation"})
 */
public function rottaAction($firstName,Request $request)
{
    var_dump($request->get('firstName'));
    exit;
}

My result is

string 'route1' (length=6)

with this routing.yml

hello:
    path: "hello/{firstName}"
    defaults: {_controller: AppBundle:Default:rotta,firstName: "route1"}

hello_name:
    path: "hello/{firstName}"
    defaults:  {_controller: AppBundle:Default:rotta, firstName: "route2"}

app:
    resource: "@AppBundle/Controller/"
    type:     annotation

My result is

string 'route2' (length=6)

and with this combination:

hello:
    path: "hello/{firstName}"
    defaults: {_controller: AppBundle:Default:rotta,firstName: "route1"}

hello_name:
    path: "hello/{firstName}"
    defaults:  {_controller: AppBundle:Default:rotta, firstName: "route2"}

#app:
#    resource: "@AppBundle/Controller/"
#    type:     annotation

my result is:

string 'route1' (length=6)

Rename route in annotation to `hello_annotation`. Route names are keys for routes in collection, so route `hello` is allways rewritten. — Max P., Apr 30 '16 at 12:05
Bonus tip: You can use `bin/console debug:router` to get all routes. — Stephan Vierkant, Apr 30 '16 at 12:19
Is your question about the order of routes in YAML vs. routes in annotations? — A.L, Apr 30 '16 at 14:38
The order is easier to understand if you don't mix yaml with annotations. Pick one or the other. Mixing them often leads to an early demise. — Cerad, Apr 30 '16 at 16:58
@Cerad Yes, I use annotation, but my purpose is to understand how symfony works — monkeyUser, May 01 '16 at 19:57

Order of Route in Symfony

0 Answers0