Elisp: Symbol's value as variable is void with let* and (lambda)

Question

Disclaimer: I started to hack around with elisp today.

I am really wondering what I am getting the following error:

Symbol's value as variable is void: response

with the following code:

(let* ((response (cons 'dict nil)))
  (nrepl-request:eval
   code 
   (lambda (resp) 
      (print resp (get-buffer "*sub-process*"))
      (nrepl--merge response resp))
   (cider-current-connection) 
   (cider-current-session)))

My understanding is that response is in the scope of the let* clause when called from the lambda function... but apparently that it is not.

This also seem to be working in this code

So I am a bit lost about why I am getting this error and what I should do about it.

With dynamic binding, the value for `response` is bound when your lambda is *defined*, but clearly that function is not being *called* within that same scope, and so `response` has no value at that point (unless it was bound elsewhere, of course). — phils, Mar 30 '16 at 20:44

Drew · Accepted Answer · 2016-03-30T23:14:16.003

You need to specify lexical binding, by setting global variable lexical-binding as a file-local variable in your source file. Put a line like this as the first line of the file:

;;;  -*- lexical-binding: t -*-

Either do that or use lexical-let* instead of let*.

Alternatively, if you do not need variable response as a variable when the anonymous function is invoked, that is, if you need only its value at the time the function was defined, then you can use this:

(let* ((response (cons 'dict nil)))
  (nrepl-request:eval
   code 
   `(lambda (resp) 
      (print resp (get-buffer "*sub-process*"))
      (nrepl--merge ',response resp)) ; <===== Substitute value for variable
   (cider-current-connection) 
   (cider-current-session)))

With the lexical variable, the lambda form gets compiled when you byte-compile the file. Without the variable (i.e., with just its value), the lambda form is not compiled -- it is just a list (with car lambda etc.).

Elisp: Symbol's value as variable is void with let* and (lambda)

1 Answers1