1

I am starting to understand Docker and as far as I am aware the docker container runs on the default Linux dist where the container is installed - in my case it's a Mac OS X lightweight dist that comes with docker toolbox.

So why do I see many Docker files actually installing a distrib inside the container, does this not defeat the object of keeping things light?

For example, here is one Docker file starting with:

    FROM debian:jessie

so this is installing a Docker image inside the container which is based on Debian.

I also see many others using Ubuntu, for example.

Can this step not be bypassed and software installed directly in the container use the underlining Linux dist where the container is installed?

halfer
  • 19,824
  • 17
  • 99
  • 186
Martin
  • 23,844
  • 55
  • 201
  • 327
  • Another example is here http://phusion.github.io/baseimage-docker/ – Martin Sep 29 '15 at 19:49
  • If your software consists of a static binary with no external dependencies, go right ahead! (I actually do this in practice in at least one case; however, it's a rare scenario). – Charles Duffy Sep 29 '15 at 20:23

1 Answers1

1

Because, just as for physical or virtual machines, setting up a userland environment is going to be a pain without a distribution.

This is, IMO, one of the strong benefits of docker: Pick the most suitable distribution for a particular application.

A containerized application is probably going to have dependencies. To install these dependencies, it helps a lot to have a package manager. Some dependencies are also included by default in many distributions, which makes it a good idea for the container creator (application) to choose its own distribution.

Additionally, remember that packaging a whole distribution does not necessarily waste a lot of resources:

  • Docker images are stored as deltas against a common baseline, meaning that two images based on debian:jessie could reuse the same data for the baseline.
  • Distributions are actually not that large, as they are usually minified versions of the full system images.

If you really want to create a minimal image, try busybox. However, you will oftentimes find yourself outgrowing it quite fast for any real world container image.

Krumelur
  • 31,081
  • 7
  • 77
  • 119