(This is a woefully late answer.) Bob are you asking for the IP address of the server that sent the reply, or the IP address for the name within a CNAME record? The canonical name (CNAME) data in a resource record (RR) portion of a DNS reply has only a domain name and a TTL. The name servers that I have tested against return an IP address for the CNAME answer in a different additional-info RR record.
If you want to read the original chapter and verse: https://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc1035.txt
Here is a bit of Python code using dpkt that lets you generate and explore the contents of DNS replies.
import dpkt
import random
import socket
# build query
query_id = int(random.random() * 10000)
query = dpkt.dns.DNS(id=query_id)
my_q = dpkt.dns.DNS.Q(name="www.yahoo.com")
query.qd.append(my_q)
sock = socket.socket(socket.AF_INET, socket.SOCK_DGRAM)
sock.connect(("8.8.8.8", 53))
sock.send(str(query))
buf = sock.recv(0xffff)
# parse response
response = dpkt.dns.DNS(buf)
if query_id != response.id:
print "Expected %d but received id %d" % (query_id, response.id)
elif response.qr != dpkt.dns.DNS_R:
print "Not a response!"
elif response.opcode != dpkt.dns.DNS_QUERY:
print "Not a query op!"
elif response.rcode != dpkt.dns.DNS_RCODE_NOERR:
print "Not a successful response!"
elif len(response.an) == 0:
print"Response has no answers!"
else:
print "%d bytes received, id is %d" % (len(buf), response.id)
for rr in response.an:
print "AN: class is %d, type is %d, name is %s" % (rr.cls, rr.type, rr.name)
if hasattr(rr, 'ip'):
print "\tIP is %s" % socket.inet_ntoa(rr.ip)
for rr in response.ns:
print "NS: class is %d, type is %d, name is %s" % (rr.cls, rr.type, rr.name)
for rr in response.ar:
print "AR: class is %d, type is %d, name is %s" % (rr.cls, rr.type, rr.name)
The results that I see (sitting on the East coast):
240 bytes received, id is 5848
AN: class is 1, type is 5, name is www.yahoo.com
AN: class is 1, type is 1, name is fd-fp3.wg1.b.yahoo.com
IP is 98.139.180.149
AN: class is 1, type is 1, name is fd-fp3.wg1.b.yahoo.com
IP is 98.139.183.24
NS: class is 1, type is 2, name is wg1.b.yahoo.com
NS: class is 1, type is 2, name is wg1.b.yahoo.com
NS: class is 1, type is 2, name is wg1.b.yahoo.com
NS: class is 1, type is 2, name is wg1.b.yahoo.com
AR: class is 1, type is 1, name is yf2.yahoo.com
AR: class is 1, type is 1, name is yf1.yahoo.com
AR: class is 1, type is 1, name is yf3.a1.b.yahoo.net
AR: class is 1, type is 1, name is yf4.a1.b.yahoo.net