How to use the same element name for different purposes ( in XML and DTD )?

Question

I Want to create a DTD schema for this xml document:

<root>

    <student>
        <name>
            <firstname>S1</firstname>
            <lastname>S2</lastname>
        </name>
    </student>

    <course>
        <name>CS101</name>
    </course>

</root>

as you can see , the element name in the course contains plain text ,but the element name in the student is complex type ( first-name, last-name ). The following is the DTD:

<!ELEMENT root (course|student)*>

<!ELEMENT student (name)>
<!ELEMENT name (lastname|firstname)>
<!ELEMENT firstname (#PCDATA)>
<!ELEMENT lastname (#PCDATA)>

<!ELEMENT course (name)>

When I want to validate it , I get an error because the course's name has different structure then the student's name .

My Question:

how can I make a work-around solution for this situation without changing the name of element name using DTD not xml schema .

Thanks.

score 12 · Accepted Answer · answered May 30 '10 at 02:38

12

Sorry! That's one of the major limitations of DTD: a given element name always has the same content model.

About all you can do is give up on full validation for that particular element, and allow all possible contents:

<!ELEMENT name (#PCDATA|lastname|firstname)*>

answered May 30 '10 at 02:38

bobince

528,062
107
651
834

Thanks @bobince , I'll use what you wrote as a work-around ,it's easier then XML-schema . – Abdullah May 30 '10 at 03:14
When using PCDATA this is the best you can do, but if all three possibilities are elements you can get slightly better results. Consider element `
`. Element `
` may contain either element ``, or elements `` and ``. We can specify this, it just won't be contextual (ie, dependant of `
`'s parent). `<!ELEMENT p (a | (b, c))>`. PCDATA has to be used as mixed content or all by itself; it can't be an either/or situation, unfortunately.
– Sandy Gifford Apr 18 '13 at 18:48

How to use the same element name for different purposes ( in XML and DTD )?

1 Answers1