ActiveRecord where and order on via-table

Question

I have three database table:

product (id, name)

product_has_adv (product,advantage,sort,important)

advantage (id, text)

In ProductModel I defined this:

public function getAdvantages()
    {
        return $this->hasMany(AdvantageModel::className(), ['id' => 'advantage'])
            ->viaTable('product_has_advantage', ['product' => 'id']);
    }

I get the advantages without any problems.

But now I need to add a where product_has_advantage.important = 1 clausel and also sort the advantages by the sort-columen in the product_has_advantage-table.

How and where I have to realize it?

Answer 1

Using via and viaTable methods with relations will cause two separate queries.

You can specify callable in third parameter like this:

public function getAdvantages()
{
    return $this->hasMany(AdvantageModel::className(), ['id' => 'advantage'])
        ->viaTable('product_has_advantage', ['product' => 'id'], function ($query) {
            /* @var $query \yii\db\ActiveQuery */

            $query->andWhere(['important' => 1])
                ->orderBy(['sort' => SORT_DESC]);
        });
}

The filter by important will be applied, but the sort won't since it happens in first query. As a result the order of ids in IN statement will be changed.

Depending on your database logic maybe it's better to move important and sort columns to advantage table.

Then just add condition and sort to the existing method chain:

public function getAdvantages()
{
    return $this->hasMany(AdvantageModel::className(), ['id' => 'advantage'])
        ->viaTable('product_has_advantage', ['product' => 'id'])
        ->andWhere(['important' => 1])
        ->orderBy(['sort' => SORT_DESC]);
}

Answer 2

Using viaTable methods with relations will cause two separate queries, but if you don't need link() method you can use innerJoin in the following way to sort by product_has_advantage table:

public function getAdvantages()
{
    $query = AdvantageModel::find();
    $query->multiple = true;
    $query->innerJoin('product_has_advantage','product_has_advantage.advantage = advantage.id');
    $query->andWhere(['product_has_advantage.product' => $this->id, 'product_has_advantage.important' => 1]);
    $query->orderBy(['product_has_advantage.sort' => SORT_DESC]);
    return $query;
}

Note than $query->multiple = true allows you to use this method as Yii2 hasMany relation.

Answer 3

Just for reference https://github.com/yiisoft/yii2/issues/10174 It's near impossible to ORDER BY viaTable() columns. For Yii 2.0.7 it returns set of ID's from viaTable() query, and final/top query IN() clause ignores the order.

Answer 4

For who comes here after a while and don't like above solutions, I got it working by joining back to the via table after the filter via table.

Example for above code:

public function getAdvantages()
{
    return $this->hasMany(AdvantageModel::className(), ['id' => 'advantage'])
        ->viaTable('product_has_advantage', ['product' => 'id'])
        ->innerJoin('product_has_advantage','XXX')
        ->orderBy('product_has_advantage.YYY'=> SORT_ASC);
}

Take care about changing XXX with the right join path and YYY with the right sort column.

Answer 5

First you need to create a model named ProductHasAdv for junction table (product_has_adv) using CRUD.

Then create relation in product model and sort it:

  public function getAdvRels()
    {
        return $this->hasMany(ProductHasAdv::className(), ['product' => 'id'])->
        orderBy(['sort' => SORT_ASC]);;
    }

Then create second relationship like this:

public function getAdvantages()
{
    $adv_ids = [];
    foreach ($this->advRels as $adv_rel)
        $adv_ids[] = $adv_rel->advantage;
    return $this->hasMany(Advantage::className(), ['id' => 'advantage'])->viaTable('product_has_adv', ['product' => 'id'])->orderBy([new Expression('FIELD (id, ' . implode(',', $adv_ids) . ')')]);
}

This will sort final result using order by FIELD technique.

Don't forget to add:

use yii\db\Expression;

line to head.

Answer 6

I`ve managed this some how... but it needs additional work after. The point is that you have to query many-to-many relation first from source model and after that inside that closure you should query your target model.

        $query = Product::find();
        $query->joinWith([
                         'product_has_adv' => function ($query)
                         {
                            $query->alias('pha');
                            $query->orderBy('pha.sort ASC');
                            $query->joinWith(['advantage ' => function ($query){
                                $query->select([
                                            'a.id',
                                            'a.text',
                                            ]);
                                 $query->alias('a');
                            }]);
                         },
                         ]);

Then you just have to prettify the sorted result to your needs. The result for each row would look like

        "product_has_adv": [
        {
            "product": "875",
            "advantage": "true",
            "sort": "0",
            "important": "1",
            "advantage ": {
                "id": "875",
                "text": "Some text..",
            }
        },

Answer 7

As explained by @arogachev, the viaTable uses two separate queries, which renders any intermediate orderBy obsolete

You could replace the viaTable with an innerJoin as follows, in a similar solution to @MartinM

public function getAdvantages()
{
   return $this->hasMany(AdvantageModel::class, ['pha.product' => 'id'])
       ->innerJoin('product_has_advantage pha', 'pha.advantage = advantage.id')
       ->andWhere(['pha.important' => 1])
       ->orderBy(['pha.sort' => SORT_ASC]);
}

By adjusting the result of hasMany, you are adjusting the query for the target class - AdvantageModel::find(); product_has_advantage can be joined via the advantage identity

The second parameter of hasMany, link, can be viewed as [ query.column => $this->attribute ], which you can now support via the joined product_has_advantage and its product identity

---

Note, when using viaTable, the link parameter can be viewed as if the intermediate query is complete and we are starting from there; [ query.column => viaTable.column ] hence ['id', 'advantage'] in your question

Answer 8

public function getAdvantages()
{
    return $this
        ->hasMany(AdvantageModel::className(), ['id' => 'advantage'])
        ->viaTable('product_has_advantage', ['product' => 'id'])
        ->andWhere(['important' => 1])
        ->orderBy(['sort' => SORT_DESC]);
}