Matlab: adding value into initialized nested struct-cell

Question

I have this structure

Data = struct('trials',{},'time',{},'theta_des',{},'vel_des',{},'trials_number',{},'sample_numbers',{});
Data(1).trials = cell(1,trials_number);
for i=1:trials_number
   Data.trials{i} = struct('theta',{},'pos_err',{},'vel',{},'vel_err',{},'f_uparm',{},'f_forearm',{},'m_uparm',{},'m_forearm',{},...
                           'current',{},'total_current',{},'control_output',{},'feedback',{},'feedforward',{},'kp',{});
end

but when I want to add a value

Data.trials{i}.theta = 27;

I get this error...

A dot name structure assignment is illegal when the structure is empty.  Use a subscript on the structure.

Any idea of how to solve it?

Thanks!

As an alternative solution, you should be able to do this: `Data.trials{i}.theta(1) = 27;` — Cris Luengo, Oct 03 '18 at 22:10

score 3 · Accepted Answer · edited Jun 20 '20 at 09:12

If you take a look at the documentation of struct, it says the following statement:

s = struct(field,value) creates a structure array with the specified field and values.

...

...

If any value input is an empty cell array, {}, then output s is an empty (0-by-0) structure.

Because your fields are initialized to {}, these are empty cell arrays, you will get an empty structure, so you are not able to access into the structure as it's empty. If you want to initialize the struct, use the empty braces instead []. In other words, in your for loop, do this:

for i=1:trials_number
    Data.trials{i} = struct('theta',[],'pos_err',[],'vel',[],'vel_err',[],'f_uparm',[],'f_forearm' [],'m_uparm',[],'m_forearm',[],...
    'current',[],'total_current',[],'control_output',[],'feedback',[],'feedforward',[],'kp',[]);
end

This should properly initialize the structure for you, and you can then access the fields accordingly. As such, if I wanted to initialize theta in the first structure within your cell array:

Data.trials{1}.theta = 27;

This will now work. You can verify the output by:

disp(Data.trials{1}.theta)

27

This works beautifully, this is the best answer I've found on the whole internet, thank's a lot! — gaborous, Nov 07 '16 at 03:52
I think he can get around this with `Data = struct('trials',{{}} ,'time',{{}}, ` etc. — crobar, Oct 03 '18 at 22:08

Matlab: adding value into initialized nested struct-cell

1 Answers1

Linked