Using macros in natvis files?

Question

I just learned about .natvis files in Visual Studio and I've been setting up some for my Ruby C++ Extension project. http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/jj620914.aspx

However, then I tried to use one of the Ruby macro's in a conditional statement then I get errors:

Natvis: C:\Users\Thomas\Documents\Visual Studio 2013\Visualizers\SUbD.natvis(79,4): Error: identifier "NIL_P" is undefined
    Error while evaluating 'NIL_P(value_)' in the context of type 'SUbD.so!SUbD::ruby::Numeric'.

The rule I'm trying is this:

<Type Name="SUbD::ruby::Numeric">
  <DisplayString Condition="NIL_P(value_)">Ruby Numeric: Nil</DisplayString>
  <DisplayString>Ruby Numeric: {value_}</DisplayString>
</Type>

In my project I am wrapping Ruby's VALUE type in small C++ wrapper classes for common types such as String, Hash, Array etc. And I've been able to set up natvis rules for these. But whenver I want to use some of the macros from the Ruby system I always get errors.

Is it not possible to use macros in natvis files?

score 1 · Accepted Answer · answered Dec 11 '14 at 12:51

http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/jj620914.aspx#BKMK_Expressions_and_formatting

"Natvis expressions are evaluated in the context of the object being visualized, not the current stack frame." The debugger cannot evaluate preprocessor macros, thus is would follow that the visualizer can't either. You would need to 'manually' expand the preprocessor macro for the expression. For example, if NIL_P is defined as:

#define NIL_P(v) !((VALUE)(v) != Qnil)

Then your natvis DisplayString tag would have to be:

<DisplayString Condition="!((VALUE)(value_) != Qnil)">Ruby Numeric: Nil</DisplayString>

Using macros in natvis files?

1 Answers1