15

I am trying to figure out a simple way to run tests on angularjs application. I am new to the testing world, so it's a little hard to understand all the options and the difference between them.

My goal: to be able to run the tests simply from within my IDE - Eclipse. And to tests the code on google chrome browser.

I found jasmine to be the obvious choice for writing js unit tests. The problem is choosing a runner both for the jasmine tests and for e2e tests.

Trying to keep it simple, I've come up with the following idea for a setup: Write the unit tests in jasmine, and the e2e tests in phantomjs and syn.js. Then configure eclipse to run phantomjs as an external tool, so that the output will go to the console in eclipse.

I also plan to have a CI job in Jenkins, and to my understanding Jenkins can also run phantom, so theoretically this solution will work the same for CI.

Alternatively, there are test running tools like Karma and Protractor. On one hand, they seem to be recommended, but on the other hand they seem to me like overkill in some cases. They require a lot of different tools/services/processes to be running in order to work, and it seems like a pain maintain all that setup if it breaks.

To my understanding: protractor runs on webdriverjs which runs on nodejs, and it requires a selenium server to be running in the background, and on top of all that the selenium opens real browser windows which seems a little pointless as opposed to headless browser testing.

Then there is Karma, that I did not yet fully understand what it's supposed to do. From what I've read it monitors the files in my project and whenever a file is changed it runs the tests. I'm not sure how it runs the tests - is it also using selenium?

And lastly, there are grunt and yeoman, which I did not understand at all what they do and how they interact or fit together with the other tools I've listed.

I would appreciate if someone could clarify what these different tools do, and how they fit together. Also, how would they fit with Jenkins as a CI server?

Also if you could comment on my "simpler setup" - does it make sense? Am I missing something?

Malki
  • 2,335
  • 8
  • 31
  • 61

4 Answers4

21

Karma is for unit testing your JS, regardless of whether it is using Angular or not. The ins and outs of unit testing with Karma are covered very well here: http://www.yearofmoo.com/2013/01/full-spectrum-testing-with-angularjs-and-karma.html. Yes, Karma opens and closes browser windows as needed and specified in the configuration file. If you don't want any browser windows opened, you can use PhantomJS. You can run Karma from within most any IDE that is capable of running an external script, or run it via the command line.

Protractor is for end-to-end (or E2E) testing of your project as a whole. It will open a browser window and click through the pages as though it were a user, entering data where you tell it to and looking for the specified results. Protractor is a bit more complicated than just writing some Jasmine, but the results are worth it. Like Karma, you can run Protractor from within most any IDE that is capable of running external scripts or via the command line.

Yeoman is a process management system that incorporates dependency management via Bower, task automation via Grunt, and project management via Yo. It will run your tests in Karma and Protractor, minify your JS, CSS, and HTML, compile everything into appropriate files (internal JS, external libraries, and CSS) and provide you with a complete package that can be deployed. The beauty of Yeoman is that it is not specific to any one IDE. Everything it does can be done by scripting in your IDE or via the command line.

Now, having said all of this about Yeoman, you do still have to write the tests (it won't magically come up with them for you) and learn to integrate it into your development routine, but it is definitely the way to go for JS development. Eclipse is fine for JS development, but you'll get better performance and ease of use (IMHO) from WebStorm.

As for how these all fit into CI like Jenkins, I believe that both Karma and Protractor output test results in a format that Jenkins can read and display. With the scripting possibilities in Jenkins you can configure it to run the build process each time your source control repository (you are using some sort of source control, aren't you?) changes and show those results on the Jenkins page. My office has a very similar setup and we use it daily. I'm not the guy that has to do the Jenkins configuration, but I do work with Yeoman (and thus Karma and Protractor) via WebStorm on a regular basis and have had very good results.

scubasteve
  • 2,718
  • 4
  • 38
  • 49
MBielski
  • 6,628
  • 3
  • 32
  • 43
  • Thanks for the answer. Follow-up question: do you ever run into problems maintaining the various tools you mentioned? Yeoman, grunt, karma, protractor, selenium... Do they ever break down, requiring you to reset / reconfigure? My main concern is the amount of knowledge every developer would need to have in order to maintain these tools – Malki Feb 13 '14 at 09:55
  • I've never had problems with any of them failing to operate. The biggest thing you need to watch for is the required version of Node.js (required to run Yeoman, Grunt, and Karma) and what version of Grunt/Karma any plugins you may use require. In general I have found the whole system very reliable and easy to use. There are a wealth of answers to be found on each one both here on SO and on the web in general. You can stay on the version you download for a very long time, or update them and stay on the edge of things. It is your choice. – MBielski Feb 13 '14 at 17:45
3

I would say the clear choice here is Karma and Protractor. While it is true that they rely on a bunch of other stuff, they do so pretty antiseptically: protractor starts up the selenium server and then shuts it off when it's done. Once you have node installed, the other installations are all super simple. I would also install httpster, which will serve up your public director on port 3333.

Frankly, having come from a decade of doing TDD in the Java world, when I first looked at Javascript a few years ago (again), the testing picture was a complete joke. But now, I think the combination of Karma and Protractor is pretty fantastic. Inside IntelliJ, you can run the Karma tests and they are stupid fast and the results are presented in a runner that's as good as anything I've seen in the Java world (Xcode 5 has the best test integration). You can also install the ddescribe plugin in IntelliJ and have a ui for running individual tests or excluding tests.

On the protractor side, I found this post because I am at the point now where I am going to run my karma, protractor and then JUnit tests on a continuous integration server (either Jenkins or TeamCity). I was kind of surprised at the paucity of info on that leg of the trip, but the clear direction I see there is Grunt, because it will run your protractor tests then generate the JUnit-style output Jenkins wants. Grunt is also a pretty impressive addition to the JS world.

I know this sounds like a bunch of opinions, but I think that as happened in the Java world, the Javascript world has now reached that level of maturity where you are just going to have to expect things to drag other things in with them. Frankly, looks like node and npm do a pretty nice job of making that pretty seamless (vs. a decade down the drain on Maven in the Java world).

Community
  • 1
  • 1
Rob
  • 11,446
  • 7
  • 39
  • 57
0

Updated: Sorry I did not read your question properly.

karma is a test runner, which is best suited for jasmine. For setting up is very very easy. Please download node, and install npm install karma. Follow the angular seed sandbox project it contains all the basic config set up for unit testing and end to end testing (in config folder).all you need is nodejs plugin installed in eclipse

Yeoman can be used for javascript minification, sass compilation e.t.c.

madhured
  • 443
  • 2
  • 8
-2

Install node eclipse and you can set all up in eclipse. http://www.nodeclipse.org/

madhured
  • 443
  • 2
  • 8
  • 1
    That's a neat project, but I don't see how it answers the question. – MBielski Feb 12 '14 at 21:29
  • karma is a test runner, which is best suited for jasmine. For setting up is very very easy. Please download node, and install npm install karma. Follow the angular seed sandbox project it contains all the basic config set up for end to end testing. Let me know if you need any help in working with it. All you need is node installed. – madhured Feb 13 '14 at 02:32