socket.io not sending connect message to client on flashsocket

Question

I'm using node.js server with socket.io plugin to connect between two clients (flash and js) on different devices

for the flash integration I'm using the FlashSocket.IO library and have io.set('transports', ['websocket', 'flashsocket']); on my .js server file

while everything works fine in most of the computers - on some computers (I don't know if it's relevant but both of the computers that I checked are running Windows 8) - the connection doesn't work

when enabling debug on the server I see that for the working clients the server send 1:: message and for the not-working clients - it doesn't

this is part of the log for working client:

  debug - client authorized
  info  - handshake authorized 8JVqPB6MuJYJeMR3RVN_
  debug - setting request GET /socket.io/1/flashsocket/8JVqPB6MuJYJeMR3RVN_
  debug - set heartbeat interval for client 8JVqPB6MuJYJeMR3RVN_
  debug - client authorized for
  debug - flashsocket writing 1::
  connected - //my console.log call on io.sockets.on('connection', ...
  debug - flashsocket received data packet 5:0+::{"args":"7087623252","name":"register"}

and for the not working client:

  debug - client authorized
  info  - handshake authorized 0nztNzwvw260Pa-bRHef
  debug - setting request GET /socket.io/1/flashsocket/0nztNzwvw260Pa-bRHef
  debug - set heartbeat interval for client 0nztNzwvw260Pa-bRHef
  debug - client authorized for
  connected - //my console.log call on io.sockets.on('connection', ...

p.s.

it doesn't seem like a firewall issue - even when the firewall is off the problem keeps happening

Thank You!

score 1 · Answer 1 · answered Mar 12 '13 at 17:47

1

I believe it is a browser related issue. From the socket.io github page :

flashsocket will not activate on Chrome or other browsers that fully support WebSockets, even if flashsocket is specified as the only transport. To test flashsocket, use IE 8 or IE 9, or other browsers that don't natively support WebSockets.

So if you want to make sure flashsocket is working correctly use IE 8/9.

answered Mar 12 '13 at 17:47

user568109

47,225
17
99
123

This comment is about fallback to flash on javascript client that doesn't support WebSockets natively - my question was about implementation of socket.io connection inside flash application. moreover, the problem occur on multiple browsers so it is not it - but thanks for your reply anyway! – Yaron U. Mar 14 '13 at 22:08

score 0 · Accepted Answer · answered Mar 24 '13 at 13:41

Eventually it was an antivirus related issue

one second before I got insane I found that the Avast that was installed on that computer blocked the connection - when the Web Shield was disabled - everything worked like a charm

(Installing the same Antivirus on my Win7 machine didn't reproduced the problem - maybe that was Win8+Avast issue)

Thanks anyway

socket.io not sending connect message to client on flashsocket

2 Answers2