Efficient way to change color of Map Marker

Question

I'm using a GoogleMap with lots of small markers loaded. We are talking perhaps 400-500 markers. Upon user interaction, I want to have a subset of those markers change color, perhaps 100-300 of them. I want to achieve this ideally in 30ms or under, but up to 50-60ms would be acceptable.

Right now I have code something like:

onUserInteraction... {
    changeColors(getTheSubset)
}

changeColors(subset) {
    getMarkersForSubset(subset).removeAllFromMap();
    map.addNewMarkers(subset)
}

So I remove the old markers in some color (say, green), and add new markers for those locations (say, black). When the subset is no longer relevant, I do the opposite process.

On the busiest parts of the map I am seeing this take 500ms or more, and there's noticeable lag with different markers changing colors at different times. So I am curious if there is a better math-based way to draw small circles on a map and change their colors without removing/adding markers and while minimizing alloc/gc.

score 0 · Answer 1 · answered Feb 13 '13 at 21:01

Have you considered using LevelListDrawables? Rather than removing and re-adding all of your markers when updating, you could have your various drawables with each color as the levels of a LevelListDrawable. Then you can call setLevel() to set the appropriate drawable with the color you want when you update your set of pins. I'm not 100% sure you can use a LevelListDrawable for the map pin, but it is worth a shot.

API: http://developer.android.com/reference/android/graphics/drawable/LevelListDrawable.html

Example: http://iserveandroid.blogspot.com/2010/10/progress-bar-implementation-using-level.html

I tried it, but you can't set an icon level on MarkerOptions. And once you set `.icon` you can't call it again apparently. — yarian, Feb 14 '13 at 20:04

score 0 · Accepted Answer · answered Mar 12 '13 at 20:55

So LevelListDrawables are not an option, due to Gmap's use of BitmapDescriptorFactory.

One solution I found was to draw a Marker on top of the old one with the new color, then delete the old one from underneath.

There were two issues to that.

One, google-maps-android-v2 doesn't support z-indexing for Markers.
Two, if you have a lot of Markers to change the color of, the performance of it causes artifacts.

Now, recently Google released an update that made Markers with a common Bitmap a lot faster to draw, but you can always throw more Markers at it and break it.

I also attempted to draw a Marker on top, but with its visibility set to false, and to then set it to true when that location got "selected". This didn't seem too much faster although in fairness I did not benchmark it.

The conclusion: Don't change Bitmaps on Markers. (For now)

Efficient way to change color of Map Marker

2 Answers2