Difference between irange and counting_range in Boost

Question

What's the difference between irange and counting_range?

I needed irange to quickly generate a range of integers like this:

auto example = boost::irange(0, 5); /// result is {0, 1, 2, 3, 4}

But noticed an example somewhere (lost the link) that talks instead about counting_range to accomplish the same task. Is there a simple explanation of the difference between these two?

This has been an incredibly scarisome example of how misinformation can be presented as authoritative and peer-reviewed fact, on SO. — Lightness Races in Orbit, Feb 01 '14 at 20:22

score 28 · Answer 1 · answered Feb 01 '14 at 20:16

The main difference is that irange is a random-access range while counting_range isn't. counting_range is based on Boost.Iterator's counting_iterator which uses all the underlying integers operations directly. Integers in C++ almost fit the iterator concept: the only thing missing is an operator*. counting_iterator provides an operator* as an identity operation and forwards everything else to the underlying type.

Another difference is that irange also supports increments different than 1.

None of them ever materialises the entire range of integers that they iterate over, so they both use O(1) memory.

score 1 · Answer 2 · answered Nov 07 '17 at 10:34

Both irange and counting_range model a random access range for integer types. As counting_ranges documentation points out, its iterator category is determined according to the following algorithm:

if (CategoryOrTraversal is not use_default)
    return CategoryOrTraversal
else if (numeric_limits<Incrementable>::is_specialized)
    return iterator-category(random_access_traversal_tag, Incrementable, const Incrementable&)
else
    return iterator-category(iterator_traversal<Incrementable>::type, Incrementable, const Incrementable&)

Therefore, for simple ranges such as boost::irange(0, 10) and boost::counting_range(0, 10) there is effectively no difference (aside from the types of each range, of course!).

However, irange also supports iteration with a different step size, e.g., boost::irange(0, 10, 2), and counting_range also supports types that are only incrementable and do not fully model an integer.

Difference between irange and counting_range in Boost

2 Answers2