When you create the modal view you are creating a new instance of the modalViewController an the modalView. This new instance knows nothing about any other instance. There are a few ways you can retain the information from previous iterations of these modal view controllers.
How I would do it:
Set up place holders in your main view and pass the values that the user selects back to the main view via a protocol and delegate setup. Then when you segue to the modal view you can load those variables in before displaying the modal view.
So let's say you have a dictionary with all of the values: {slider = YES, someValue=10,...} Create that dictionary in the main view controller, the first one that opens, and place some default values in it.
In your modal view controllers create the same dictionary as a property.
Create a protocol in your modal view controller with a method that is something like
- (void) doneEditing:(NSDictionary *)values
Set up your first view as the delegate for the modal view controller and in the implementation of doneEditing copy the values to the dictionary that is present in the first view before popping the modal view.
When the first view is ready to present the modal view again, copy the values to the dictionary property of the modal view before presenting it.
I hope this gets you headed in the right direction. It's important to remember that each time you segue or create and present a modal view you are creating a brand new instance of that view, it knows nothing about the previous instance at all unless you tell it something about it.
