hopefully this is pretty open and shut, but here's the situation.
I used LetsEncrypt and CertBot to set my website www.blueprintstats.com up with an SSL certificate. Now, I realized after the fact that I had to add blueprintstats.com (no www) separately, and made that change. All good!
If you go to these links, you can see that I am in the clear on both: https://www.ssllabs.com/ssltest/analyze.html?d=www.blueprintstats.com&hideResults=on
https://www.ssllabs.com/ssltest/analyze.html?d=blueprintstats.com&hideResults=on
However, when I go to either in Chrome, I am still getting "Not Secure". I read online that unlike DNS changes, these are not cached, and thus that is not the problem.
Does anyone see what is going on here? I even tried restarting apache (no luck).