1

I'm looking for a simple answer.

I have a server here that's identical to our primary server. I want to make this server our backup server.

Can someone point me to a resource or mention the services I need?

If the primary server fails, I want our backup server to pickup DHCP / Directory / DNS services and keep copies of the files from the primary server.

Would that mean simply failover clustering? Can you do that on two servers or do you need at least three?

user506427
  • 21
  • 2
  • 1
    "We do not support combining the AD DS role and the failover cluster feature" -- Microsoft. Even if you could, a domain controller cannot participate in a cluster, and a cluster isn't needed for DHCP/DNS high availability. For file system high availability, DFS namespaces may be an option. – Greg Askew Jan 22 '19 at 16:29
  • 1
    @GregAskew not to nitpick, but DFS namespaces is the "wrong" tool for true Windows filesystem HA. It can work and is way cheaper to set up than real FS clustering, but a true failovercluster is the only Microsoft way to Fileserver-HA. – Lenniey Jan 22 '19 at 16:42

1 Answers1

2

Failover clustering, as you mention, is probably your best bet here. You need a minimum of 2 servers (not 3, thankfully).

Your best options would be either to:

  • Individually cluster the services running atop the 2 physical servers (i.e. install AD,DHCP,DNS on each of the physical servers and make them aware of one another using their native functionality) or my preferred option:
  • Build a Windows Failover Cluster atop your two physical servers, and then create clustered roles on that Failover Cluster (either directly, or inside of VMs). This approach has a number of advantages (I advise you to research it in more detail), but automated failover and live migration are two of my favourites.

The latter option will require you to have (among other pre-requisites), a shared storage medium, and identical server hardware, as well as multiple NICs, etc.

The MS docs on the topic are dense, but very helpful - I highly recommend that you read through them.

As an aside - most of the roles you've mentioned are actually best deployed as pairs (or more) such as AD-DS, DNS, DHCP, etc - rather than having an active/backup relationship - but I still recommend that you familiarise yourself with failover clustering as an option.

BE77Y
  • 2,667
  • 3
  • 18
  • 23