On a dev server with one IP I have several domains and sites and they have been working fine coexisting with different SSL certs. When adding a new dev site and binding it to SSL I accidentally saved the binding without the [ ] Require Name Server Indication.
Now I cannot undo it simply by turning it on. What is happening is that the last domain saved (with checkbox off) wins for all sites on the server. if I last uncheck it for abc.com it breaks xyz.com, I can make the same mistake on xyz.com and it breaks abc.com. it doesn't recover by going back and marking the checkbox.
How can I recover?
I have stepped through each site with SSL and see the checkbox on and even toggled each from the needed cert to the IIS dev cert and back - but after doing all the issue still persists.