20

Every time I make coffee it seems to taste different, and I've found there is a lot more room for error with the manual drip-brew method than using a Moka coffee maker or an automatic drip-brewer.

There are too many variables to list, but I'll try:

  • Type/color/brand of filter
  • Amount of coffee
  • Wetting the filter
  • Wetting the grounds
  • Amount of time between wetting the grounds and pouring the rest of the water
  • Plastic / ceramic / glass cone
  • Coarseness of the grounds
  • Rate of water flow
  • Temperature of water
  • Height from which to pour water
  • Trickling water or constant pour
  • Clockwise / counterclockwise / or straight-on pouring
  • Whether to fill it up to the brim and let it seep down or be patient and pour a little at a time
  • And many more.

But what are the most important factors (either from this list or anything I might have missed) that I need to do every time to ensure that the cup is a most excellent brew? How do those factors actually affect the brew and why?

Please include only factors specific to, or of particular import to this method of coffee brewing.

Peter Turner
  • 503
  • 2
  • 7
  • 17
  • This sounds like "manual drip", so I've edited your question a bit. – Bob Jan 31 '11 at 18:22
  • It's actually more commonly called a [drip brew](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drip_brew), although technically a funnel could refer to a percolation method as well. – Aaronut Jan 31 '11 at 18:26
  • 1
    I also wouldn't ask people to pick 3, because that just encourages people to focus on ranking as opposed to explaining. I'm kind of interested in the answers myself, so I took away the "top 3" reference in addition to tidying up some of the terminology. – Aaronut Jan 31 '11 at 18:28
  • @aaronut, isn't that just going to encourage people to answer in the form of a list? – Peter Turner Jan 31 '11 at 18:34
  • @Peter: I wouldn't think so, since you've already pretty much given the list. Asking explicitly for an explanation certainly couldn't hurt though, assuming that's what you want. (It is your question after all, not mine, but based on your comments to Bob, I'm assuming you want more than a point-form answer). – Aaronut Jan 31 '11 at 19:02
  • 2
    Single most important item missing from the list is freshness of the coffee; and freshness of the grind. If you use prepackaged already-ground coffee for example, your day-over-day taste change may be as much related to staleness as to the other factors. – sdg Feb 01 '11 at 21:28
  • 1
    I'm starting a bounty on this question. I will award it to the first person who **actually includes reasonably-detailed explanations**. I'm very unhappy with the answers so far, which basically either say "it depends" or "this is what I do". Fine, but **how** does it depend, and **why** do you do those things? – Aaronut Feb 02 '11 at 20:09
  • @aaronut, thanks a lot. I'm not particularly satisfied with non-drip brew oriented answers as well. I've heard this can be quite an art form. – Peter Turner Feb 02 '11 at 21:27
  • Why would you use a filter rather than a cafeteria/french press. Assuming you are only making one or two cups rather than a pot - it seems easier and I always thought better to have the water and the coffee mixed together rather than it briefly running through. – Martin Beckett Feb 04 '11 at 23:57
  • @mgb, 2 reasons, 1. It's really cheap (got a melitta travler for 8 bucks) 2. Very little cleanup - so I can make it quietly every morning. Also, I remember Alton Brown on Good Eats saying and demonstrating this to be the best possible way to make a cup of coffee. – Peter Turner Feb 05 '11 at 16:06
  • @mgb they are also very portable. Compared to any other device, if you're doing some extended backpacking one of the little plastic ones is quite an asset (although those pyrex french presses are nice b/c they double as crush-resistant storage for the coffee supplies) – mfg Feb 08 '11 at 16:41
  • @mfg - I misundertood what the OP meant. I was thinking of the jug coffee machine. I have a Bodum Solo Drip that does exactly this. It has a permanent filter so no mess and the inner filter part controls how long the water spends in the coffee – Martin Beckett Feb 09 '11 at 18:05

6 Answers6

17

Background

The manual drip technique (AKA "filtercone brewing") and an automatic drip-brewer are very similar; both involve pouring water through a conical filter into a vessel. The difference is that an automatic drip-brewer maintains consistent and hopefully ideal conditions, so when you drip-brew manually, you are essentially trying to recreate the environment inside an automatic drip-brewer.

Much of the following is derived from sweetmarias.com - my constant source for coffee information.

Customizing your coffee

The most important variables in terms of how much they affect the end result also happen to be easily isolated variables that you can control simply with tools. They are:

  1. Temperature of the water

    The best temperature is when the water is just coming to a boil, around 200° F or 93.3° C. An automatic drip-brewer will generally maintain a temperature of between 195° F and 205° F.

    Water that is too cold won't extract enough of the oils and will give you flat, flavorless coffee. Water that is too hot will extract a lot of the proteins and give you very bitter coffee.

    This is simple to control for; just use a thermometer, or learn how to recognize when the water is just about to boil.

  2. Coarseness of the coffee

    The grind (obviously, a fresh grind especially) is important here, as it is with any distillation method. What you need to remember is that you are matching the temperature and pressure of extraction.

    For high pressure extraction (espresso), uniformly fine grind is preferred to ensure that the water does not shoot past the puck too quickly. For lower pressure methods (i.e. manual drip), you want a medium grind to ensure that the water passes easily but not too quickly.

    Again, this is simple to control for; just use a good, reliable coffee grinder.

  3. Ratio of water to coffee grounds

    This is mainly a matter of personal preference. Figure out what you like, but ensure that this is the final variable you are isolating. Use a measuring spoon, start at 8 grams (about 1 rounded tablespoon) per 5 oz water, and start experimenting from there.

Improving your consistency

Once you've dealt with the obvious factors above, proper technique becomes essential to improving on the consistency of your brewing process. You'll want to watch out for:

  1. Steady heat during the pour

    Depending on the material your filter cone is made of, it may take a while to heat up, which means that initially the water will lose heat to the cone and become too cold before it passes through the coffee.

    You can compensate for this by pre-heating the cone. Use hot water for this; don't use the microwave, especially if it's a plastic cone.

    Ceramic cones are more heat-stable than plastic, but will take longer to heat up, so it's more important to pre-heat them. You probably don't need this stability because the water shouldn't be in the cone for too long - unless you're brewing a full pot. Most pour-overs should really only be for about 20 ounces of coffee.

  2. Pour Time

    The best automatic coffee makers have a sprinkle head and pour out over a deliberately extended period of time, as opposed to shoving the coffee through in a rush. This is because you are trying to extract flavor as thoroughly as possible, and quick is not thorough.

    Maintain a slow, steady pour. Trickling is less effective since it will cause an uneven leaching from the grinds, so be wary of this. Submerging is even less effective because you will lose heat from your water as it sits there. This is probably the most important part of a good brewing technique.

    It should take 4-5 minutes, pouring evenly over all the grinds, to extract a full 10 cup pot. Hopefully your arm is strong or you're only doing 1 cup.

    More practically, you will want to refer to this chart on specific infusion times: For example, for a #4 filter, and 20 ounces of coffee, you will want to spend 2 minutes and 30 seconds on the infusion (they recommend 32g or ~4 rounded Tbsp of coffee).

  3. Wetting the filter

    This applies when your filter falls down (as wetting it keeps it up) - not a big problem with conical filters. That said, in some cases rinsing off your filter is preferred in the event that your filter gives an off-flavor. I personally have never encountered this with unbleached filters.

  4. Wetting the grounds

    There are two schools of thought on this. Some say to do it, others say not to do it because it locks up the oils or stales the coffee when done too far in advance.

    In the case of a straight pour over filter, non-vacuum, sweetmarias.com recommends "blooming the coffee 15-30 seconds" by sprinkling with a pre-pour. (I assume that's what 'wetting the grounds' meant. In my experience, premature moisture is less of a problem for beans with more sugar, i.e. lighter roasts.)

    As for time between wetting filter/grounds, you should minimize wetness of coffee in the interest of freshness by thermal conservation, or refrain from either step.

  5. Height of pour

    This matters mainly because you don't want to splash water or grinds everywhere, but more importantly you don't want the water to lose heat on its way down by pouring too far.

  6. Rotation of pour

    Pick one, do it evenly across all grinds. The important thing here is consistency.

Miscellaneous tips and tricks

  • According to sweetmarias on the quantity of coffee:

    Simply using more coffee grinds cannot fix other brew problems: If you use 20 grams coffee and 350 ML of water and 4 minutes steep time to achieve 20% extraction (it should), using 40 grams coffee with a contact time of 1 minute to compensate will not result in a better cup.

  • Consider removing the drip before the final drops go through. According to Voilley et al., Eval., 287:

    Perceived coffee bitterness is lower when coffee is brewed hot than when cooler water is used. This is hypothesized to be due to the heightened aromatics released in hot coffee, which counteract the bitterness.

    So watch out for those last few drops, because they will tend to have lost some heat and will thus leach more solids with fewer aromatics, resulting in more bitterness.

Now go enjoy some hand cranked coffee consistently.

Community
  • 1
mfg
  • 11,709
  • 11
  • 61
  • 110
  • I've heard to wait 30 seconds after wetting the grounds. I think the one thing that it does do is ensure that your initial few seconds of pouring doesn't go right through the grounds. I've tried both ways, and you just get clear liquid if you don't wet them. – Peter Turner Feb 02 '11 at 21:31
  • @Peter The thirty seconds pause I have heard yea/nay on. Some people claim *not wetting* and pouring hot water directly on causes "shock", perhaps wetting allows for an even introduction to leeching. Myself, I avoid wetting the (surface of the) grounds prior to pouring as a stiffer surface breaks up the evenness of your pour. – mfg Feb 02 '11 at 21:34
  • 1
    @Peter I looked further into the 15-30 sec pre-pour and updated with some info, it sounds mixed. Since I do not pre-pour using a pour over, I included my take on the pre-pour based on what happens when coffee gets wet. – mfg Feb 03 '11 at 00:04
  • 1
    This is much closer to the level of detail I was hoping for. I'd like to clean it up (style/formatting), do you mind a fairly large edit (assuming no actual content changes) or would you rather it be left alone? – Aaronut Feb 03 '11 at 16:42
  • @Aar No that's okay, I have been trying to figure out how to re-word due to the edits on pre-soaking and how to give a measured consideration on that. If you re-boot this it will help me to do touch up (if necessary) – mfg Feb 03 '11 at 18:04
  • I accepted this answer because it's objectively awesome. But I've got one last question you might be able to edit into the answer. Can the last 10-20 seconds of drainage spoil the cup, should I remove the filter after I'm done pouring water - or let everything go into the cup? – Peter Turner Feb 08 '11 at 15:08
  • 1
    @Peter I added a note for you. The link is fantastic in terms of how a cup becomes bitter over the brewing process. The metric they use is based on the taste threshhold of various compounds in the coffee. In a big automatic pot you probably wouldn't notice those last bits; but in 8-20 ounces of coffee it could carry over that threshhold more noticeably. – mfg Feb 08 '11 at 15:41
  • Alright, this is a pretty major overhaul but I haven't changed any of the content, just restructured a lot of it and added some more detailed explanations here and there. I think this is much more readable, but you're welcome to roll it back if you like. – Aaronut Feb 09 '11 at 02:02
  • Definitely more readable, I wish there were upvotes for edits. Thanks @aar – mfg Feb 09 '11 at 11:46
  • Actually from experience and if your in no hurry, if you pour very hot water (pre-boiling) over your grounds to wet them prior to turning on the coffee maker it will allow them cook a little bit. I usually let it sit for about 1 minute and I have found that this substantially improves overall flavor of the coffee, this is particularly important for small brews of a cup or two. – emalamisura Feb 13 '13 at 19:35
5

If I had to pick a top 3, it would be:

  • Ratio of grounds to water
  • Coarseness of the grind
  • Temperature of the water

These three factors are usually very dependent on the technique used, so you need to get them right for "manual drip". The quality of the beans and the water are also quite important, but not dependent on the technique used.

Bob
  • 7,202
  • 2
  • 29
  • 37
  • That's probably right, if you don't mind, I'd like to rephrase my question to say, "except for Bob's answer, what's the 3 most important things to worry about when making coffee via this technique" – Peter Turner Jan 31 '11 at 18:18
  • Maybe I'll just wait to see if someone else answers (thanks for the edit too) – Peter Turner Jan 31 '11 at 18:21
  • Don't forget the speed. More than 30' will extract flavors you'd like to avoid. – BaffledCook Feb 01 '11 at 19:08
  • The original question just asked for a top 3. I don't think the downvote is particularly fair, but I'll edit this later to better answer the current question. – Bob Feb 02 '11 at 20:53
4

One of the single biggest influences on the flavor of coffee is the flavor of the water used. Since there isn't any reason to have electrolytes, salts and other minerals compete with the flavor of coffee and its aromatic oils, I highly suggest using only distilled water. Independent of the hand drip brew, automatic drip machines should not have water that might be hard or have other minerals to deposit running through its innards.

Adam S
  • 1,241
  • 8
  • 11
  • 2
    Along the same lines... I get the water from the tap the night before and let it sit in the pot before brewing. This allows dissolved gasses like chlorine some time to evaporate out. Sounds strange, but there is a noticeable difference. – Ray Feb 03 '11 at 03:30
2

I am a coffee geek, and I drink great coffee EVERY day. The most important part of the equation is to use freshly roasted coffee. I roast my own coffee beans once per week.

If you can't roast your own beans, buy them from a roaster that roasts and ships on the same same day. It is important that they put the roast date on the bag. I have had about ten different varieties from Counter Culture Coffee, and they have all been great. I store the coffee beans in the freezer, in sealed mason jars.

My wife is not so much a geek. Here are the very detailed instructions I wrote up for her to follow (when her coffee valet is not available) to make a single cup of coffee:

  1. Take down a standard 10 ounce coffee cup and the Hario one-cup drip device
  2. Put 2.5 cups of water in electric kettle. Plug it in and turn it on
  3. Place a Hario filter in the drip device. Leave this on the countertop by the sink
  4. Open top of gram scale, turn it on, wait for it to reset zero grams
  5. Place small pyrex bowl on top of scale. Press the "Tare" button, wait for it to reset
  6. Pour coffee beans into pyrex bowl to a weight of 13 grams
  7. Remove the glass bowl with coffee beans. Turn off gram scale and close the top
  8. Pour coffee beans into coffee grinder. Press Start button once to wake it up.
  9. Press Start button again to grind the beans.
  10. When you hear it go into "high speed", there are no more beans to grind.
  11. When water has come to a boil, pour it into the silver Hario tea kettle
  12. Remove the hopper with ground coffee, empty it into Hario filter in the one-cup device
  13. Place the one-cup device on top of the coffee cup
  14. Pour a small amount of water into the coffee grounds. Set a timer for 30 seconds
  15. When the timer goes off, you can start pouring water very slowly into the grounds.
  16. Don't fill the entire cone - halfway is high enough.
  17. As you start pouring the water, you can hear it "tinkling" into the bottom of the coffee cup
  18. When the cup becomes about 2/3 full, the sound will stop. This is due to the shorter distance that the water falls before it meets what is already in the cup.
  19. Now you should check the height of the coffee in the cup to see when to stop. The Hario drip device has a handle, so you can easily lift it to peek at the coffee.
  20. I fill the coffee cup almost to the top. I remove the Hario drip device when I have about 1/4 inch left at the top of the cup. This gives me 9 ounces of coffee.
  21. Most people drink their coffee too hot. The flavor develops and becomes more complex when it sits for at least one minute, and it cools a few degrees.
Rick G
  • 564
  • 2
  • 7
  • 1
    This is a lot of detail (great) but I don't see any explanations. Why is freshly-roasted coffee important - what is its effect? Why Hario? Why 2.5 cups to 13 grams? Why the 30-second soak? Everybody has their own methods to follow to make a perfect cup according to *their own* preferences, but what we're getting at, or at least what I'd like people to be getting at, is how can people move beyond trial-and-error or blindly following instructions and determine how to get coffee exactly how *they* want it? What's the theory behind it? – Aaronut Feb 03 '11 at 03:41
  • I don't understand step 11, why do you need 2 tea kettles? Personally, I have a problem with my kettle I use on the stove, I can't pour it very evenly, so I usually just drip it down the side - but I've heard this is no good because it cools the water down too much. – Peter Turner Feb 03 '11 at 14:12
  • @Aar Sorry, I misinterpreted the original question. When you try to explain the theory, things are not so clear cut. A lot of what I have read on CoffeeGeek.com, Home-Barista.com and GreenCoffeeBuyingClub.com simply says "Try this approach, see if it gives you better results". And that is what I posted - where I ended up after trying other people's suggestions. – Rick G Feb 04 '11 at 03:57
  • @Peter the Hario kettle is specially designed to allow you to pour the water VERY slowly. Heating the water up in the electric kettle gets it to the boiling point ASAP. At that moment, the water is too hot for brewing coffee. SO I pour it into the Hario to dissipate some heat, and pre-wet the grounds for 30 seconds. When I actually start pouring the water into the filter cone, it is in the desirable range of 195 to 205 degrees. – Rick G Feb 04 '11 at 04:00
  • @Aar I clarified the end of the pour. I don't use all 2.5 cups of water to make a single cup of coffee! There is no magic recipe for quantity of water to ground coffee. I started with the guidelines at Sweet Maria's and modified them to something that my wife and I could agree on as the "best" flavor. – Rick G Feb 04 '11 at 04:11
1

In my experience, most of the items on your list have very little effect on the resulting brew. The only ones I'd worry about are:

  • Amount of coffee
  • Coarseness of the grounds
  • Temperature of water

Even water temp isn't very important, as long as the water is boiling hot.

Amount of coffee and coarse/fine grind is partly a matter of taste. Manual drip is a fairly fast brewing method, so you normally use a fine grind. One thing I like about brewing this way is that I can use a cheap whirling blade grinder (they don't work very well at coarse grinds).

I like strong coffee, so I use about 2-3 tablespoons of beans for a cup. This is the easiest thing to play around with.

You didn't mention grinding your own coffee from beans, that's the first thing to do to get good coffee - don't buy ground coffee, buy beans, store them somewhere cool (not in the fridge or freezer or they'll get spoiled by water condensing on them), and grind them as you need them.

Ward - Trying Codidact
  • 4,947
  • 11
  • 32
  • 45
1

Being slightly aggressive in your pour (with a gooseneck kettle) can help provide a fuller extraction - after the gentle pre-brew is completed.

Aaronut
  • 54,811
  • 24
  • 191
  • 303
Kurt
  • 11
  • 2