Questions tagged [hardlink]

Links a name with actual data (file). Hard-linking allows the file to have multiple names (handles). Present in POSIX-compliant systems (also only partially!): GNU/Linux, Android, Apple Mac OS X and even Windows, though with limitations. Allows for slightly different aliasing than soft-linking (aka symbolic linking) - there are trade-offs to each methods.

In a nutshell

Files contain data. Filenames point to files. If you have more than one name pointing to the same file, you have a hard link.

Most file systems support hard links, but not all (FAT, for one, doesn't). Usually this means keeping track of the number of distinct filenames used for a particular file; the filesystem then continues to make file content available for access as long as at least one hard link is left. If you ever wondered why C uses unlink to remove files, that's the reason: it doesn't remove the file, it removes the fileNAME and decreases the aforementioned reference counter.

Hard vs soft linking

Two hard links to a given set of content will reference the same inode. In other words, they are different names for the same file. A soft link to a file is a different file (its own inode) which contains data pointing to a target.

MyFile in (say) inode 3333 can have "my text" as its data. MyHardLink will point to the same inode, 3333 and thus will have same data. MySoftLink will be a different file, occupying a different inode (say, 3334) and its data will be a pointer to the name MyFile.

Illuminating and illustrated! explanation of both concepts by Lew Pitcher, from Linux Gazette.

Limitations

Hardlinks cannot point to a parent of the directory containing them. This avoids endless recursion. There is also generally a limit on how many hard links can be made to the same inode, stemming from the reference counter stored by the filesystem; if too many hardlinks were to be created to one inode, the reference count would overflow. These limits are usually are worked around with symbolic links, and are very well described on Wikipedia.

Additional Windows limitations

  1. The minimum client and server Windows OS supporting hardlinks are - correspondingly - XP and Server 2003.
  2. Windows hard links are NTFS-only.
  3. NTFS uses 10 bits for the filename counter, so there can be only 1023 distinct names per file.

MSDN page on Hard Links

Windows API for CreateHardLink function

192 questions
0
votes
1 answer

Finding files that are Hardlink in Soalris under specific folder

I need to find hardlink files under specific folder in Solaris. Tried this below command which lists the files based on inode count. find . -type f -links +1 The above command list both source and target files. But i need to list only the…
0
votes
1 answer

How to determine if two file are hard-linked to the same data?

I've written an extension method for the System.IO.FileInfo class to create hard-link and it goes like this: [DllImport("Kernel32.dll", CharSet = CharSet.Unicode)] private static extern bool CreateHardLink(string lpFileName, string…
B. Bergeron
  • 90
  • 1
  • 10
0
votes
1 answer

Python - overwrite a link if it exists

from os import link link('WInd_Rose_Aguiar.svg', 'Wikipedia Daily Featured Picture') # A day has passed link('Piero_del_Pollaiuolo_-_Profile_Portrait_of_a_Young_Lady_-_Gemäldegalerie_Berlin_-_Google_Art_Project.jpg', 'Wikipedia Daily…
user4385532
0
votes
1 answer

Same word files in multiple directories without admin right for multiple users

I'm facing a problem at my current project where multiple users need to access hundreds of Word .docx files in multiple directories. They don't have any admin rights to their Windows 10 computers and they wish to have version control connected to it…
Sam
  • 418
  • 2
  • 6
  • 18
0
votes
1 answer

hard links refererring to a file ant stat st_nlink don't match

Using Ubuntu 18.04 bash, if I list all files that share the same specific inode 4 with: sudo find -inum 4 -printf "%D %i %n %p\n" 2>/dev/null I can see different values of the number of hard link for that same specific inode (=4). The same occur…
programmer
  • 41
  • 6
0
votes
1 answer

Differences between creating a file linked with symbolic links and hard links

I have read some posts about symbolic links and hard links, but I would like to confirm my concept on this as there is a certain behaviour that is quite unclear to me. Consider this sequence of command line instructions. $ echo abc >file1 $ ln file1…
Prashin Jeevaganth
  • 1,223
  • 1
  • 18
  • 42
0
votes
1 answer

Using .config/directory as a git repo

The whole configuration for a soft is located in .config/soft. Lately, I had an idea to practice basic git usage by initializing a git repo to which I would send commits with config changes. My question is that I am not sure if I should initialize…
user8544907
0
votes
0 answers

Data Block Id Retrieval

If two files a and b are hard-linked to a data block A, is it possible to get the link-id or the id of the data block the files are linked to and retrieve the data without the files ?
d_rex
  • 11
  • 3
0
votes
1 answer

Create hardlink/symlink from windows on unix networkshare

Is it possible to create a hardlink/symlink on networkshare that is on linux but from windows environemnt which has access to that share? Lets say that I have a file on networkshare: \share\test.txt and I want to create hardlink (or symlink)…
Snorlax
  • 787
  • 2
  • 9
  • 22
0
votes
0 answers

Finding the Target of a Link produces NIO Exception but works with ShellFolder under Windows

I am doing a recursive search for different types of files within a folder tree. Upon finding a .csv file during the search, I scan the file with a BufferedReader and put the results in to a database for further operations. The application works…
Audrey Delany
  • 113
  • 4
  • 12
0
votes
2 answers

When some process has a file open, what will unlink() do?

From APUE #include int unlink(const char *pathname); Only when the link count reaches 0 can the contents of the file be deleted. One other condition prevents the contents of a file from being deleted: as long …
Tim
  • 1
  • 141
  • 372
  • 590
0
votes
1 answer

Editing hard or softlink's target location content with PHP

I know this is a security threat and is bad from a security aspect alltogether, but for a specific reason, i need this to work. I have a program running on Ubuntu 16.04. Let's say for this example, that it's a DNS server or whatever. What i'm trying…
0
votes
0 answers

git: how to create hardlink between objects of two existing repos

I have two git clone (say A and B ) from a commun huge origin. They are both on the same disk/partition. I want them to share by hardlink their commun objects. I could create a new local copy "git clone A C" and add B as a remote fetch everything…
0
votes
2 answers

What really happens when deleting file

Let's say that I created a file. A new inode has created. Then I created a soft link to that file, and deleted the hard link. Does the inode still exist? Does it point to the same location in the memory? Is the soft link connected to the inode that…
Asher
  • 57
  • 1
  • 7
0
votes
3 answers

bash if then cp as hardlinks

I would like for the following to hardlink all files to destination, except those directories defined. The find piece is working, but it won't copy any files. #!/bin/sh tag_select=$1 source=$3 dest="/backup/" { if [[ "$1" = "backup" ]]; then …