Counting how many time a relation is pointing at the same key

Question

SELECT t.tag_name
FROM tags t
 JOIN resource_tags rt ON rt.tag_id = t.tag_id
 JOIN resource r ON r.resource_id = rt.resource_id
 JOIN visitor_resource vr ON vr.resource_id = rt.resource_id
 JOIN visitor v ON v.visitor_id = vr.visitor_id
WHERE v.visitor_id = '1'
GROUP BY t.tag_name

As you might see, a 'visitor' visits a 'resource' and a relation between them will be created in visitor_resource.

A given 'resource' have a couple of 'tags' depending on the content, and they are bound together by a relation in resource_tags.

The above query outputs the tag-names for all the resources that a visitor have visited.

Now I want to find out how many times a tag is represented.

Consider the following: Resource 1: tag1, tag2 Resource 2: tag1 Resource 3: tag2 Resource 4: tag1

The query should output: tag1, 3 tag2, 2

I have tried with the following:

SELECT t.tag_name, SUM(t.tag_id) as cnt
 FROM tags t
 JOIN resource_tags rt ON rt.tag_id = t.tag_id
 JOIN visitor_resource vr ON vr.resource_id = rt.resource_id
 JOIN visitor v ON v.visitor_id = vr.visitor_id
WHERE v.visitor_id = '2'
GROUP BY t.tag_name

But that seems to have exceptionally unreasonable high numbers for cnt, and not counting for this specific user.

Is this even possible with MySQL?

score 1 · Answer 1 · answered Apr 21 '11 at 14:00

1

You are doing a SUM on the ID, not a COUNT.

You're basically adding up the auto-generated values of your tags, which is going to give you a much higher result than simply adding up the occurrences.

answered Apr 21 '11 at 14:00

Paul Alan Taylor

10,474
1
26
42

Dude, mistakes like this happen to all of us. I've lost count of the times when I've done the exact opposite boolean operation to what I intended :) – Paul Alan Taylor Apr 21 '11 at 14:04

score 1 · Answer 2 · answered Apr 21 '11 at 14:02

1

It appears your problem might because you are doing SUM instead of COUNT

SELECT t.tag_name, COUNT(t.tag_id) as cnt

instead of

SELECT t.tag_name, SUM(t.tag_id) as cnt

should do it.

answered Apr 21 '11 at 14:02

Naraen

3,240
2
22
20

ypercubeᵀᴹ · Accepted Answer · 2011-04-21T14:07:16.210

Use: COUNT(t.tag_id)

and not SUM(t.tag_id).

It's also more common to group by the id (primary key) and perhaps faster as the index can be used for the grouping. The tag_name may not have an index.

SELECT t.tag_name
     , COUNT(t.tag_id) AS cnt
FROM tags t
  JOIN resource_tags rt ON rt.tag_id = t.tag_id
  JOIN visitor_resource vr ON vr.resource_id = rt.resource_id
  JOIN visitor v ON v.visitor_id = vr.visitor_id
WHERE v.visitor_id = '2'
GROUP BY t.tag_id

Counting how many time a relation is pointing at the same key

3 Answers3