Using @Gil Goldzweig's suggestion, here is what I did: in case of an Instagram like comments' system with replies, I did use a nested recyclerView system. It just makes it easier to add and remove items. However, as for the question How does one properly send data to child adapter in a fragment? You don't. It gets super messy. From my fragment, I sent the data to my mainAdapter, which in turn sent the data to the relevant childAdapter. The key to make it smooth is using notifyItemRangeInserted when adding a comment to the mainAdapter and then notifyItemChanged when adding replies to a comment. The second event will allow sending data to the child adapter using the payload. Here's the code in case other people are interested:
Fragment
class CommentsFragment : androidx.fragment.app.Fragment(), Injectable,
SendCommentButton.OnSendClickListener, CommentsAdapter.Listener {
@Inject
lateinit var viewModelFactory: ViewModelProvider.Factory
private val viewModel by lazy {
ViewModelProviders.of(requireActivity(), viewModelFactory).get(CommentsViewModel::class.java)
}
private val searchViewModel by lazy {
ViewModelProviders.of(requireActivity(), viewModelFactory).get(SearchViewModel::class.java)
}
private val mAdapter = CommentsAdapter(this)
private var contentid: Int = 0 //store the contentid to process further posts or requests for more comments
private var isLoadingMoreComments: Boolean = false //used to check if we should fetch more comments
override fun onCreateView(inflater: LayoutInflater, container: ViewGroup?,
savedInstanceState: Bundle?): View? {
return inflater.inflate(R.layout.fragment_comments, container, false)
}
override fun onActivityCreated(savedInstanceState: Bundle?) {
super.onActivityCreated(savedInstanceState)
//hide the action bar
activity?.findViewById<BottomNavigationView>(R.id.bottomNavView)?.visibility = View.GONE
contentid = arguments!!.getInt("contentid") //argument is mandatory, since comment is only available on content
ivBackArrow.setOnClickListener{ activity!!.onBackPressed() }
viewModel.initComments(contentid) //fetch comments
val layoutManager = LinearLayoutManager(this.context)
layoutManager.stackFromEnd = true
rVComments.layoutManager = layoutManager
mAdapter.setHasStableIds(true)
rVComments.adapter = mAdapter
setupObserver() //observe initial comments response
setupSendCommentButton()
post_comment_text.setSearchViewModel(searchViewModel)
setupScrollListener(layoutManager) //scroll listener to load more comments
iVCancelReplyTo.setOnClickListener{
//reset ReplyTo function
resetReplyLayout()
}
}
private fun loadMoreComments(){
viewModel.fetchMoreComments(contentid, mAdapter.itemCount)
setupObserver()
}
/*
1.check if not already loading
2.check scroll position 0
3.check total visible items != total recycle items
4.check itemcount to make sure we can still make request
*/
private fun setupScrollListener(layoutManager: LinearLayoutManager){
rVComments.addOnScrollListener(object: RecyclerView.OnScrollListener(){
override fun onScrolled(recyclerView: RecyclerView, dx: Int, dy: Int) {
super.onScrolled(recyclerView, dx, dy)
val visibleItemCount = rVComments.childCount
val totalItemCount = layoutManager.itemCount
val pos = layoutManager.findFirstCompletelyVisibleItemPosition()
if(!isLoadingMoreComments && pos==0 && visibleItemCount!=totalItemCount && mAdapter.itemCount%10==0){
//fetch more comments
isLoadingMoreComments = true
loadMoreComments()
}
}
})
}
private fun setupSendCommentButton() {
btnSendComment.setOnSendClickListener(this)
}
override fun onSendClickListener(v: View?) {
if(isInputValid(post_comment_text.text.toString())) {
val isReply = mAdapter.commentid!=null
viewModel.postComment(post_comment_text.text.toString(), mAdapter.commentid?: contentid, isReply) //get reply ID, otherwise contentID
observePost()
post_comment_text.setText("")
btnSendComment.setCurrentState(SendCommentButton.STATE_DONE)
}
}
override fun postCommentAsReply(username: String) {
//main adapter method to post a reply
val replyText = "${getString(R.string.replyingTo)} $username"
tVReplyTo.text = replyText
layoutReplyTo.visibility=View.VISIBLE
post_comment_text.requestFocus()
}
override fun fetchReplies(commentid: Int, commentsCount: Int) {
//main adapter method to fetch replies
if(!isLoadingMoreComments){ //load one series at a time
isLoadingMoreComments = true
viewModel.fetchReplies(commentid, commentsCount)
viewModel.replies.observe(this, Observer<Resource<List<Comment>>> {
if (it?.data != null) when (it.status) {
Resource.Status.LOADING -> {
//showProgressBar(true)
}
Resource.Status.ERROR -> {
//showProgressBar(false)
isLoadingMoreComments = false
}
Resource.Status.SUCCESS -> {
isLoadingMoreComments = false
mAdapter.addReplies(mAdapter.replyCommentPosition!!, it.data)
rVComments.scrollToPosition(mAdapter.replyCommentPosition!!)
}
}
})
}
}
private fun isInputValid(text: String): Boolean = text.isNotEmpty()
private fun observePost(){
viewModel.postComment.observe(this, Observer<Resource<PostCommentResponse>> {
if (it?.data != null) when (it.status) {
Resource.Status.LOADING -> {
//showProgressBar(true)
}
Resource.Status.ERROR -> {
//showProgressBar(false)
}
Resource.Status.SUCCESS -> {
if(it.data.asReply){
//dispatch comment to child adapter via main adapter
mAdapter.addReply(mAdapter.replyCommentPosition!!, it.data.comment)
rVComments.scrollToPosition(mAdapter.replyCommentPosition!!)
}else{
mAdapter.addComment(it.data.comment)
}
resetReplyLayout()
//showProgressBar(false)
}
}
})
}
private fun setupObserver(){
viewModel.comments.observe(this, Observer<Resource<List<Comment>>> {
if (it?.data != null) when (it.status) {
Resource.Status.LOADING -> {
//showProgressBar(true)
}
Resource.Status.ERROR -> {
isLoadingMoreComments = false
//showProgressBar(false)
}
Resource.Status.SUCCESS -> {
mAdapter.addComments(it.data)
isLoadingMoreComments = false
//showProgressBar(false)
}
}
})
}
private fun resetReplyLayout(){
layoutReplyTo.visibility=View.GONE
mAdapter.replyCommentPosition = null
mAdapter.commentid = null
}
override fun onStop() {
super.onStop()
activity?.findViewById<BottomNavigationView>(R.id.bottomNavView)?.visibility = View.VISIBLE
}
}
MainAdapter
class CommentsAdapter(private val listener: Listener) : RecyclerView.Adapter<CommentsAdapter.ViewHolder>(), ChildCommentsAdapter.ChildListener {
//method from child adapter
override fun postChildReply(replyid: Int, username: String, position: Int) {
commentid = replyid
replyCommentPosition = position
listener.postCommentAsReply(username)
}
interface Listener {
fun postCommentAsReply(username: String)
fun fetchReplies(commentid: Int, commentsCount: Int=0)
}
class ViewHolder(val view: View) : RecyclerView.ViewHolder(view)
private var comments = mutableListOf<Comment>()
private var repliesVisibility = mutableListOf<Boolean>() //used to store visibility state for replies
var replyCommentPosition: Int? = null //store the main comment's position
var commentid: Int? = null //used to indicate which comment is replied to
override fun onCreateViewHolder(parent: ViewGroup, viewType: Int): ViewHolder {
val view = LayoutInflater.from(parent.context)
.inflate(R.layout.item_comment, parent, false)
return ViewHolder(view)
}
override fun onBindViewHolder(holder: ViewHolder, position: Int) {
val comment = comments[position]
with(holder.view) {
//reset visibilities (rebinding purpose)
rVReplies.visibility = View.GONE
iVMoreReplies.visibility = View.GONE
tVReplies.visibility = View.GONE
content.loadUserPhoto(comment.avatarThumbnailURL)
text.setCaptionText(comment.username!!, comment.comment)
tvTimestamp.setTimeStamp(comment.timestamp!!)
val child = ChildCommentsAdapter(
//we pass parent commentid and position to child to be able to pass it again on click
this@CommentsAdapter, comments[holder.adapterPosition].id!!, holder.adapterPosition
)
val layoutManager = LinearLayoutManager(this.context)
rVReplies.layoutManager = layoutManager
rVReplies.adapter = child
//initial visibility block when binding the viewHolder
val txtMore = this.resources.getString(R.string.show_more_replies)
if(comment.repliesCount>0) {
tVReplies.visibility = View.VISIBLE
if (repliesVisibility[position]) {
//replies are to be shown directly
rVReplies.visibility = View.VISIBLE
child.addComments(comment.replies!!)
tVReplies.text = resources.getString(R.string.hide_replies)
if (comment.repliesCount > comment.replies!!.size) {
//show the load more replies arrow if we can fetch more replies
iVMoreReplies.visibility = View.VISIBLE
}
} else {
//replies all hidden
val txt = txtMore + " (${comment.repliesCount})"
tVReplies.text = txt
}
}
//second visibility block when toggling with the show more/hide textView
tVReplies.setOnClickListener{
//toggle child recyclerView visibility and change textView text
if(holder.view.rVReplies.visibility == View.GONE){
//show stuff
if(comment.replies!!.isEmpty()){
Timber.d(holder.adapterPosition.toString())
//fetch replies if none were fetched yet
replyCommentPosition = holder.adapterPosition
listener.fetchReplies(comments[holder.adapterPosition].id!!)
}else{
//load comments into adapter if not already
if(comment.replies!!.size>child.comments.size){child.addComments(comment.replies!!)}
}
repliesVisibility[position] = true
holder.view.rVReplies.visibility = View.VISIBLE
holder.view.tVReplies.text = holder.view.resources.getString(R.string.hide_replies)
if (comment.repliesCount > comment.replies!!.size && comment.replies!!.isNotEmpty()) {
//show the load more replies arrow if we can fetch more replies
iVMoreReplies.visibility = View.VISIBLE
}
}else{
//hide replies and change text
repliesVisibility[position] = false
holder.view.rVReplies.visibility = View.GONE
holder.view.iVMoreReplies.visibility = View.GONE
val txt = txtMore + " (${comment.repliesCount})"
holder.view.tVReplies.text = txt
}
}
tvReply.setOnClickListener{
replyCommentPosition = holder.adapterPosition
commentid = comments[holder.adapterPosition].id!!
listener.postCommentAsReply(comments[holder.adapterPosition].username!!)
}
iVMoreReplies.setOnClickListener{
replyCommentPosition = holder.adapterPosition
listener.fetchReplies(comments[holder.adapterPosition].id!!, layoutManager.itemCount) //pass amount of replies too
}
}
}
@Suppress("UNCHECKED_CAST")
override fun onBindViewHolder(holder: ViewHolder, position: Int, payloads: MutableList<Any>) {
if(payloads.isNotEmpty()){
//add reply to child adapter
with(holder.view){
Timber.d(payloads.toString())
val adapter = rVReplies.adapter as ChildCommentsAdapter
if(payloads[0] is Comment){
adapter.addComment(payloads[0] as Comment)
}else{
//will be of type List<Comment>
adapter.addComments(payloads[0] as List<Comment>)
val comment = comments[position]
if (comment.repliesCount > comment.replies!!.size) {
//show the load more replies arrow if we can fetch more replies
iVMoreReplies.visibility = View.VISIBLE
}else{
iVMoreReplies.visibility = View.GONE
}
}
}
}else{
super.onBindViewHolder(holder,position, payloads) //delegate to normal binding process
}
}
override fun getItemCount(): Int = comments.size
//add multiple replies to child adapter at pos 0
fun addReplies(position: Int, newComments: List<Comment>){
comments[position].replies!!.addAll(0, newComments)
notifyItemChanged(position, newComments)
}
//add a single reply to child adapter at last position
fun addReply(position: Int, newComment: Comment){
comments[position].replies!!.add(newComment)
comments[position].repliesCount += 1 //update replies count in case viewHolder gets rebinded
notifyItemChanged(position, newComment)
}
//add a new comment to main adapter at last position
fun addComment(comment: Comment){
comments.add(comment) //new comment just made goes to the end
repliesVisibility.add(false)
notifyItemInserted(itemCount-1)
}
//add multiple new comments to main adapter at pos 0
fun addComments(newComments: List<Comment>){
comments.addAll( 0, newComments) //loading comments or previous comments go to the beginning
repliesVisibility.addAll(0, List(newComments.size) { false })
notifyItemRangeInserted(0, newComments.size)
}
}
The childAdapter is very basic and has nearly 0 logic.
